Sitting in the Seat of Moses

– posted by meleti
At Matthew 23:2-12, Jesus condemned the prideful scribes and Pharisees for burdening men with heavy loads.  He said, in verse 2, that they had "seated themselves in the seat of Moses."

What did he mean by that?  Why pick Moses instead of other faithful men like Abraham, King David, Jeremiah, or Daniel?  The reason was that Moses was the Law Giver.  Jehovah gave the law to Moses and Moses gave it to the people.  This role in pre-Christian times was unique to Moses.

Moses talked face to face with God.  (Ex 33:11)  Presumably, when Moses had to make a concession to the law code, such as the certificate of divorce, he did this after discussing it with God.  Yet Moses was the one seen as giving the law. (Mt 19:7-8)

Someone who sits in the seat of Moses makes himself into a lawgiver, the intermediary between God and men.  Such a man presumes to speak for God and to lay down rules that are to be obeyed; rules carrying the force of divine law. This was what the scribes and Pharisees were known for doing.  They would even go so far as to punish with disfellowshipping (expulsion from the synagogue) any who defied their rules.

The Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses has often used the rebellion of Korah to denounce anyone who should dare to question any of their directives to the congregation.  So if those who question the dictates of the Governing Body are likened to Korah, whom should we liken to Moses?  Who, like Moses, is making rules that men must obey as if from God?

In the video from last week's CLAM (Christian Life and Ministry) meeting, you were taught that it is more important to attend the meeting you are assigned to then to provide the proper means of life for your family.  (1Ti 5:8) Please note that the brother in question could have gone to the same meeting at a different time in another congregation and thus have avoided all the suffering and stress his family experienced for many months.  Yet, because he refused that way out, he is put forward as an example of Christian integrity for all to follow.

So the rule that is being held up as so important that one should be willing to sacrifice the physical and financial well being of one's family, even at the risk of failing to obey the command at 1 Timothy 5:8, is a rule of men.  Men, not God, are telling us that attending the meetings at the congregation where we are assigned is of such vital importance that any challenge to our attendance is a test of faith.

Putting a rule of man up at the level where failure to comply is seen as a question of integrity firmly seats the Rule Maker in the seat of Moses.

Archived Comments

We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.

  • Comment by PoetryofProvidence on 2016-08-27 13:40:59

    Truly it must create some consternation at HQ for those assigned to "track the troublemakers" who still attend the Hall and go home and dismantle their "theology" publicly . It brings me some great sense of delight when it is done with such ease and accuracy .

  • Comment by AndereStimme on 2016-08-27 14:17:51

    Video is such a powerful tool. You can give a clear message that, when challenged, can be plausibly denied. It's not in print. It wasn't explicitly stated. "No brother, we never said that. We never told you to quit your job, we never told you to hang up on your disfellowshipped relatives and we never told you that if you just went to meetings and out in service your life circumstances would dramatically improve. And we certainly never said we'd give you even one red cent if the implied promise of a 'better job with shorter hours and closer to home' doesn't come true. Obviously you lack faith, brother."

    • Reply by Truth-Seeker on 2016-10-07 11:36:08

      Yes, videos have a subtle and yet profound effect on the psyche. All they have to show is a ringing telephone that the mother doesn't pick up and millions of mothers throughout the world know what the GB wants them to do with their dfed children.

Recent content

 This past weekend, on April 12, 2025, Jehovah’s Witnesses around the world gathered for their annual observance of the Lord’s Supper. But it’s a most unusual meal—because although millions attend, hardly anyone…

Hello everyone,Jehovah’s Witnesses are taught that their reward for faithful obedience to the Governing Body will be to live on a paradise earth. That idea is reinforced thousands of times in JW.org publications, videos…

Hello everyone. In our previous video, we learned that the Bible never actually says that we go to heaven. This can be difficult for many to accept because they’ve grown up with the idea that heaven is a place where…

Hello everyone.It seems that whenever I do a video explaining why all Christians should be partaking of the bread and wine at the Lord’s Supper, I get comments like these:“But I don’t want to go to heaven. I just want to…

Hello everyone.If you are a loyal member of the religion of Jehovah’s Witnesses, you need to stop for a moment and ask yourself a few important questions. Questions like: Why were circuit overseers directed to tell…

Hello everyone.In the previous video, we learned that the view Jehovah’s Witnesses, Seventh-day Adventists, and other apocalyptic religions have concerning the great tribulation is false. Those religions need their…