“他正在等待這座擁有真正基礎的城市,其設計師和建造者是上帝。” –希伯來書11:10
[研究31從08年20月2日至28月04日,第2020/XNUMX頁,第ws]
開頭一段聲稱“MILLIONS of God's people today have made sacrifices.今天有數以百萬計的上帝子民作出了犧牲。 Many brothers and sisters have chosen to remain single.許多兄弟姐妹選擇保持單身。 Married couples have postponed having children.已婚夫婦推遲生育。 Families have kept their lives simple.家庭過著簡樸的生活。 All have made these decisions for one important reason—they want to serve Jehovah as fully as possible.所有人做出這些決定都是出於一個重要原因-他們希望盡可能全面地為耶和華服務。 They are content and trust that Jehovah will provide all the things they truly need.”.他們對耶和華將提供他們真正需要的一切東西感到滿意和信任。”
True, millions of brothers and sisters have made sacrifices, but many now regret it, they are not content.的確,成千上萬的兄弟姐妹做出了犧牲,但現在許多人為此感到遺憾,他們不滿意。 The author personally knows a number who either had no children or did not have a second child, all because the Organization convinced them that Armageddon would come in 1975, and when that did not happen, that it was imminent.作者本人認識一個沒有孩子或沒有第二個孩子的人,所有這些都是因為本組織說服他們相信世界末日會在XNUMX年發生,而當那件事沒有發生時,那即將到來。 By the time they realized it was not coming then it was too late for them to have a child.到他們意識到還沒有來的時候,對他們來說生孩子已經為時已晚。 It is also true that many remained single, particularly sisters, because they could not marry a Christian, only one of Jehovah's Witnesses, and the brothers are in short supply.的確,許多人仍然是單身,特別是姐妹,因為他們無法嫁給一名基督徒,只有一名耶和華見證人,而兄弟倆供不應求。
當說家庭過著簡單的生活時,真正的意思是,由於缺乏進一步的教育,他們負擔不起更多的錢,而常常依靠別人。 實際上,一對前宣教士夫婦將經濟上的幫助變成一種藝術形式,總是聲稱自己貧窮,並提到他們“為耶和華服務”的記錄,以迫使兄弟姐妹為他們提供免費的住宿,免費的膳食或家具。 實際上,他們去時與近來的證人免費住了近兩年的房子。
The other big question is as to whether Jehovah will provide all the things they truly need.另一個大問題是耶和華是否會提供他們真正需要的一切。 Why do we say this?為什麼這樣說呢? One of the few scriptures that suggests this is possible is Matthew 6:32-33.馬太福音607:1914-XNUMX是表明這是可能的少數經文之一。 But if the Governing Body and the Organization are teaching falsehoods, which they know they are, (XNUMX BCE and XNUMX AD being a case in point, and the remnant/other sheep teaching) and ignore justice for the vulnerable ones within its ranks, then would God accept that those following every instruction of the Governing Body are actually seeking first the kingdom of God and his righteousness?但是,如果管理機構和本組織正在傳授他們所知道的虛假信息(例如公元前XNUMX年和公元XNUMX年,還有剩餘/其他綿羊的教義),而忽略了其職級中的弱勢群體的正義,那麼上帝會接受那些遵循領導機構每一項指示的人實際上首先是在尋求上帝的國度和他的公義嗎?
The Study article claims that Jehovah would bless them because he blessed Abraham.該研究文章聲稱,耶和華會祝福他們,因為他祝福亞伯拉罕。 However, can we really compare the actions of Abraham with the actions of any brother or sister or our own?但是,我們真的可以將亞伯拉罕的行為與任何兄弟姐妹或我們自己的行為進行比較嗎? Hardly.幾乎不。 Abraham was given clear instructions by an angel and he obeyed them.亞伯拉罕得到天使的明確指示,他聽從了。 Jehovah and Jesus do not communicate with anybody on earth today via angels.耶和華和耶穌今天不通過天使與世上任何人交流。
In paragraph 2 it mentions that Abraham willingly left a comfortable lifestyle in the city of Ur.在第6段中,提到亞伯拉罕願意在烏爾市留下舒適的生活方式。 This lays the ground for suggestions later in the article.這為本文後面的建議奠定了基礎。 To lay further groundwork for these suggestions paragraphs 12-XNUMX exaggerate any difficulties Abraham had.為進一步為這些建議打下基礎,第XNUMX至XNUMX段誇大了亞伯拉罕遇到的任何困難。
For example, he dwelt in tents instead of in a city with fortifications and a moat on three sides, and hence was more vulnerable to attack.例如,他住在帳篷裡,而不是住在設防設防和護城河在三個側面的城市中,因此更容易受到攻擊。 That is true, but there is no record of Abraham being attacked until many years later in the land of Canaan.的確如此,但直到多年以後,在迦南地才有亞伯拉罕遭到襲擊的記錄。 It also mentions that at one time he struggled to feed his family.它還提到,他曾一次努力養家糊口。 That also is true, but most of the time he had plenty.事實也是如此,但是大多數時候他都很多。 Yes, Pharaoh took his wife Sarah, but that could partly be put down to the fact that because of fear of man Abraham told Pharaoh that Sarah was his sister when asked, rather than the truth, that she was his wife.是的,法老王娶了妻子莎拉為妻,但這可以部分歸因於這樣一個事實:由於擔心男人,亞伯拉罕告訴法老王,當被問到莎拉是他的妹妹時,而不是事實,她是他的妻子。 He had family problems, but many of these were due to having two wives, which inevitably brings many of the problems he experienced.他有家庭問題,但其中許多是由於有兩個妻子,這不可避免地帶來了他經歷的許多問題。 We should also not forget though that in Genesis 15:1 Jehovah told Abram in a vision that he would be a shield (or protection) for him.耶和華在創世記XNUMX:XNUMX中告訴亞伯蘭,他將為他作盾(或保護),但我們也不應忘記。
這一切使我們進入了第13段,在“模仿亞伯拉罕的榜樣”標題下,該段告訴我們我們應該“願意做出犧牲”。
本組織建議我們做出什麼樣的犧牲?
It puts forward the example of Bill (from 1942!!!).提出了比爾(XNUMX年起!!!)的例子。 Does the Organization not have any more modern examples to use?本組織沒有更多現代例子可使用嗎?
Bill即將與耶和華見證人一起學習時,即將畢業於美國大學,獲得建築工程學位(一項非常有用的工作和資格)。 His professor already had a job lined up for him.他的教授已經為他準備了一份工作。 However, he refused this offer of a job.但是,他拒絕了這份工作的提議。 Although it does not make it clear, likely as a result he was very soon after drafted for military service (as likely the job occupation had he accepted may have kept him exempt from the draft).儘管沒有清楚說明,但很可能是他被徵召入伍後很快就被徵召入伍(很可能是他接受的工作佔領使他免於徵兵)。 He then had to waste three years in prison as a result.結果,他不得不浪費三年的徒刑。 He was later invited to Gilead and served as a missionary in Africa.後來他被邀請到基列,並在非洲擔任傳教士。
因此,建議的犧牲是:
- 即使您即將畢業,也要放棄大學學位(經過3至5年的辛勤工作和大量的花銷)。
- 看著嘴裡的禮物馬,然後拒絕它(為您排好隊的好工作將被拒絕。)
- 相反,應在監獄中成為政府的客人。
- 放棄生孩子,所以您可以當傳教士。
要替換它,將為您提供以下服務:
- 作為傳教士,在本組織內具有誘人的“地位”的胡蘿蔔(如今很難做到)。
- (如果您有膽量忽略這一事實)。
- 傳教你的學生的事工說謊,並期望他們做出同樣毫無意義的犧牲。
(在城市裡生活比今天要稀有得多。)
第14段警告我們明顯 “不要指望自己的生活沒有麻煩”。
This is part of the double-speak from the Organization.這是本組織雙重發言的一部分。 In one part of the article, they will say在文章的一部分中,他們會說 “不要指望自己的生活沒有麻煩” and then in the other they will say or as here, they quote almost the exact opposite.然後他們會說另一種話,或者像這裡一樣,引用幾乎完全相反的話。 In paragraph 15, Aristotelis says在第XNUMX段中,亞里斯多德利斯說 “耶和華總是給我克服這些問題所需的力量”。 Now that is his view, but others in his situation would not say the same despite relying on Jehovah as they believe and are told to do.現在這是他的觀點,但處於他處境中的其他人儘管相信並被告知要遵守耶和華,卻不會說同樣的話。 Could it not be that Aristotelis has a stronger character and will-power or is mentally stronger than others and that is what kept him going.亞里士多德不是擁有更強的性格和意志力,還是不是精神上比其他人更強,這就是讓他前進的原因。 What evidence do we have that Jehovah specifically communicated with Aristotelis or amended his circumstances or gave him the holy spirit, so he had the strength to overcome these problems?我們有什麼證據可以證明耶和華與亞里士多德之間進行了專門的溝通,或者改變了他的處境,或者給了他聖靈,使他有能力克服這些問題? From Aristotelis' statement, many brothers and sisters would conclude that provided they prayed they would be able to handle anything.從亞里士多德的陳述中,許多兄弟姐妹得出的結論是,只要他們祈禱自己能夠處理任何事情。 In Brother Lett's talk on the Saturday Afternoon Regional convention program (2020) about the resurrection, he said在萊特弟兄在星期六下午區域會議計劃(XNUMX)上關於復活的講話中,他說 “義人將包括許多親人,他們可能以為自己會活著看到事物系統的終結”。 Yes, there are many brothers and sisters who believed that Armageddon would be here by now, (including my parents), which the Organization led them to expect.是的,有許多兄弟姐妹(包括我的父母)相信世界末日將在這裡(包括我的父母),這是本組織帶領他們期望的。 As a result, they expected they would not need a pension, or they would not face debilitating health problems in this system.結果,他們期望他們不需要退休金,或者他們不會在這個系統中面臨使人衰弱的健康問題。 Now, they have had to face them and many have not been able to overcome them either mentally or physically or financially, resulting in depression, suicide, and severe financial hardship.現在,他們不得不面對他們,許多人在精神上,身體上或經濟上都無法克服它們,從而導致沮喪,自殺和嚴重的財務困難。
One thing we can guarantee, if you avoid studying the scriptures for yourself and instead swallow every teaching from the Governing Body without question, your life will definitely not be trouble-free.我們可以保證的一件事是,如果您避免自己學習經文,反而毫無疑問地吞噬了領導機構的所有教teaching,那麼您的生活肯定不會一帆風順。 Why do we say this?為什麼這樣說呢? Because you will suffer many self-inflicted problems due to making life-affecting decisions based on lies (teachings known to be false by the GB, such as 1914 and blood transfusions) and conjecture, which has been presented as truth.因為您將基於謊言(GB已知為錯誤的教學,例如XNUMX年和輸血)和猜想而做出會影響生命的決策,因此您會遭受許多自欺欺人的問題,這些猜想被視為事實。
總之,這篇守望台研究文章中唯一真正有用的部分(而不是偏向於推動組織而不是推進神的王國)是克諾爾弟兄對妻子的建議。 “展望未來,因為那裡是您的回報所在”和“保持忙碌-嘗試用自己的生活為他人做些事情。 This will help you to find joy.”這將幫助您找到快樂。”
At least that suggestion is similar to what Abraham did.至少該建議類似於亞伯拉罕所做的。 Abraham looked to the future, helped others (such as his nephew Lot), and obeyed God's instructions rather than men's.亞伯拉罕放眼未來,幫助他人(例如他的侄子羅得),並服從神的指示,而不是人的指示。
大家好,我願意。 我在愛爾蘭都柏林擔任守望台監督者達15年之久。 上面引用的文章是一種典型的麵包和黃油,一直在不斷攪拌,令我遺憾的是,我主持了這本書。 一旦進入了野獸的身體,下面的內容就顯得如此顯而易見:純粹是對權威的掠奪!恐怕事實表明,他們在冷光中完全是妄想... 閱讀更多 ”
重新租房,同時靠別人生活。
有一對夫婦申請了“低息貸款”並獲得了貸款,因此他們可以開創先河。 這些貸款的錢被提供給特殊情況,以便他們可以買一間普通的房子。 這對夫婦選擇低收入。 所用的錢應該已經流到了另一個家庭。
I was disgusted.我很噁心。 We were getting marked as being materialistic when we built our own place which was very basic.當我們建立自己的非常基本的場所時,我們被標記為是唯物主義的。 Where were supposed to live in a tree?應該在哪裡住在樹上?
越南。 許多美國人不會知道澳大利亞也捲入了這場戰爭。 這是通過徵兵與正規部隊一起完成的。 我被召喚了。 我註冊為“出於良心拒服兵役”,但在我的案子出現之前沒有通過醫療檢查。 現在,wt正在告訴被征服者未啟用替代服務。 wt還告訴我,即長者告訴我說,這都是我自己的想法,所以不要讓我們參與。 戰爭爆發一段時間後,wt決定在美國許多人已經徵召入伍者的情況下,可以進行其他工作... 閱讀更多 ”
98桿8-15增強我們對上帝公義的信心***過去,一些見證人因拒絕參加他們的良心現在可能允許的活動而受苦。 17允許耶和華因拒絕他現在沒有後果而可能遭受的苦難是不義的? Most who大多數人... 閱讀更多 ”
Oui,je suisécœuréede cette虛偽! Tout les WJ saven bicqueest LASOCIÉTÉqui imposaient CONTRE notre conscience cette ligne de導管。 維爾紐斯新城(2月1日至24月XNUMX日),“合作社”,“合作社”,“推特”,“推特”中央政府將法新社批准為基督自願教廷,並由法國自律委員會批准。 Mais ilParaîtqu'ils n'ont pas... 閱讀更多 ”
Ocasionandodañoa mis hijos por hacerles觀測塔塔斯萊里斯人文。 Dios sabe que fuiste sincera,no me pidasperdón,empieza a mirar el futuro y enterra el pasado sino nopodrásanar tu mente ycorazóndeldañode la WT»。 No sólo perjudicaría a mis hijos, también perdí la oportunidad de ir a la Universidad.不能因為大學而錯過任何機會。 Ahora tengo problemas de salud y dificultades económicas經濟概論與經濟概論... 閱讀更多 ”
Isn't it amazing that they can get away with handing out bad advice and issuing mandates that go beyond scripture, then have the nerve to tell us how we should feel about the negative consequences of following their mistaken teachings.他們可以發出糟糕的建議並發布超出聖經的授權,然後逃脫挑戰,然後有勇氣告訴我們,對於他們錯誤的教following帶來的負面後果,我們有何感觸,這並不令人驚訝。 I don't believe that any religious organization is favored by God.我不相信任何宗教組織都受到上帝的青睞。 We are to be disciples of Christ, but that does not involve any specific manmade organization.我們要成為基督的門徒,但這不涉及任何具體的人為組織。 While I don't agree with all of the teachings of mainstream churches, I still treat these people as Christians;儘管我不同意主流教會的所有教義,但我仍然將這些人視為基督徒。 brothers and sisters in my faith.我信仰的兄弟姐妹。 My personal opinion is that Christians will continue我個人認為基督徒會繼續... 閱讀更多 ”
“長老告訴我說,這都是我自己的想法 因此,不要讓我們參與其中-非常正確,請說您的良心不允許您服兵役。 但是,如果由我決定,為什麼我不能服兵役? 無能為力-您將失去聯繫。 如果該死,該死,如果不這樣做,該死。
謝謝塔杜阿。 這是我讀的那些WT文章之一,目的是使自己免受離開WT的任何疑問。 就像很多藥物一樣,它對我有好處,令人反感,這使我想起我做出了正確的選擇,並且應該避免男人做出的犧牲。 我特別喜歡您的文章中的這一段:“我們可以保證的一件事是,如果您避免自己學習經文,而毫無疑問地吞噬了理事機構的所有教definitely,那麼您的生活絕對不會遇到麻煩。 為什麼這樣說呢? 因為你會遭受很多... 閱讀更多 ”
現在是個人的……1942年,是嗎? 1942年,我的父親是一個活躍的JW,並悄悄地接受了一些大專學歷,以便他可以從事技術工作,而不會陷入就業市場的低谷。 然後草案來了。 像所有證人一樣,他拒絕上崗,並考慮時間,拒絕上崗使一個人成為賤民。 嚴格以平民身份向他提供“和平替代服務”,但指示他不要接受,因為這仍然是對他正直的侵犯。 他去了監獄,但是當他發現... 閱讀更多 ”
哇,切特,好喝!
?????
謝謝。
Hi Chet, Thank you for sharing with us your very personal heartfelt comments.切特,您好,非常感謝您與我們分享您的個人意見。 They were made in a dignified way but pulling no punches.它們以莊重的方式製造,但不費吹灰之力。 Your experience is the sad consequences of honest hearted God fearing people being conned by the greatest con-artists.您的經歷是誠實善良的上帝懼怕人們被最偉大的藝術家騙取的悲慘後果。 I used to say to those I met from door to door, that this way of living (as a JW) was the best way of living even if it was not true.我曾經對我挨家挨戶碰到的人說,這種生活方式(作為JW)是最好的生活方式,即使事實並非如此。 Now I, like you, know different, to our cost and the cost of those we love around us.現在,我和您一樣,對我們的成本和我們周圍所愛的人的成本了解不同。 Yes, the GB have some reckoning ahead of是的,GB之前有一些評估... 閱讀更多 ”
As I said at the outset, now it's personal.正如我一開始所說的,現在是個人的。 To have the unmitigated gall to bring up an example like that, from 1942, is simply stupid on their part, and I believe indicative of how few examples they have to choose from.從XNUMX年開始,讓未受束縛的膽子舉起這樣的例子,簡直是愚蠢的,我相信這表明他們必須選擇的例子很少。 By using someone that has probably been deceased for years, they don't have to worry about that person waking up and repudiating the whole thing.通過使用可能已經死去多年的人,他們不必擔心該人醒來並否認整個事情。 It's easy to talk about such an example, but it doesn't end when that person is released from prison.談論這樣的例子很容易,但是當那個人被釋放時並沒有結束。 This is a disruption of someone's life and a setback that can affect them這是對某人生活的破壞,可能會影響到他們的挫折... 閱讀更多 ”
切特
您提出的有趣的經文,似乎是聖經的證據,證明流放者離開後70年的歷史(在巴比倫,而不是在耶路撒冷被毀之後)已經開始,否則耶利米為什麼要像他在第10節中那樣寫信給他們? 來自NWT: 10 “因為這就是耶和華說的:'當巴比倫活了70年,我便將注意力轉向你,+ 我會把您帶回這個地方,以兌現我的諾言。”+
Hi Chet.切特If only those that need to read what you have written would read it.如果只有那些需要閱讀您所寫內容的人會閱讀它。 Considering the scant regard they have given to questions in letters I have written, they would not understand it.考慮到他們對我寫的信中對問題的漠視,他們不會理解。 They are not to be questioned, as they have no answers.他們沒有問題,因為他們沒有答案。
在這一點上,他們是盲目的,無法自我檢查。
出色的論點,持續不斷的發展。 Los de cuerpo gobernante son unoshipócritasdescarados,viven en lujo desvergonzado y losno publicados deben hacer todos los sacrificios,ja,ja…igual que Jesucristo que noteníadonde recostar su cabeza
There was a time when the Watchtower Society was far more modest than it is now.曾經有一個時候,the望塔協會比現在要謙虛得多。 That certainly has changed.那肯定已經改變了。
The Governing Body continues to carefully examine its navel, keeping itself occupied with itself.管理機構繼續仔細檢查其肚臍,讓自己忙碌起來。 Christians not marrying for the sake of promoting the Good News has been practiced since the beginning of Christianity and continues today.自基督教開始以來,就一直在為宣揚好消息而沒有結婚的基督徒一直沿用至今。 Choosing not to have children in order to be free to sacrifice their lives in full service has also been practiced and continues to be in various Christian faiths.選擇不生孩子以自由地全力奉獻自己的生命,這種做法一直存在,並且仍然存在於各種基督教信仰中。 Promoted and supported by the leadership.領導層的推動和支持。 What is also found in organized religion is the life led by the higher ups.在有組織的宗教活動中還發現有高等貴族生活。 They are free from want, all is provided.他們沒有匱乏,提供了一切。 This is true of Archbishops and大主教和... 閱讀更多 ”
Yes, agreed.是的,同意。 Well said.說得好。