Jehovah’s Witnesses are told that the spiritual nourishment provided by the Governing Body in The Watchtower is just what is needed at any given point in time. Typical of this view are these WT references:
“For us today, it means having confidence in “the faithful and discreet slave” appointed to give us our spiritual “food at the proper time,” as well as in those from among them who form the Governing Body.” (w98 8/15 p. 12 par. 11 Jehovah Should Be Our Confidence)
“Another blessing that Jehovah has bestowed upon us is the great body of Scriptural truth. As we feast on an abundance of rich spiritual food, we have reason to “cry out joyfully because of the good condition of the heart.” (w11 2/15 p. 19 Do You Really Appreciate Your Blessings? Subheading “Food at the Proper Time”)
A rich and abundant feast brings to mind the picture of bountiful plates of food of every type to satiate even the hungriest, most malnourished invitee. It does not conjure up the image of tables filled with jugs of milk and bowls of porridge.
“The naive person believes every word, But the shrewd one ponders each step.” (Pr 14:15 NWT 2013)
Not wanting to be categorized as “naive persons”, let us review our spiritual diet over the past year to see if it has come as advertised.
w13 11/15 (December 30 - February 2)
THEME: Be obedient to our leadership because Armageddon is close.
Article 1: Advice on Prayer. The end is near.
Article 2: Don't doubt. Be patient. The end is near.
Article 3: Obedience. Salvation depends on staying in the Organization.
Article 4: Obedience. Salvation depends on obeying the elders.
Article 5: Counsel to elders.
w13 12/15 (February 3 - March 2)
THEMES: Don't doubt the Governing Body. Avoid apostates. Make sacrifices. You are not to partake.
Article 1: Beware apostates.
Article 2: Donate to and serve the Organization.
Article 3: We have the right date. Only the chosen few should partake of the emblems.
Article 4: Continuation of Article 3 themes.
w14 1/15 (March 3 - April 6)
THEMES: Don't doubt the Governing Body. We are in the last days. The end is near. Make sacrifices.
Article 1: 1914 is true, Jehovah is king since then. (Christ too.)
Article 2: Authority of Governing Body reaffirmed. We must not doubt.
Article 3: Make sacrifices.
Article 4: Make sacrifices because the end is near.
Article 5: New proof that the end is near ("this generation” – Take 7).
w14 2/15 (April 7 - May 4)
THEMES: We are special. It's good to be one of the other sheep. Stick to the Organization.
Article 1: Partial prophetic misapplication of Ps. 45 to reinforce role of anointed.
Article 2: Partial prophetic misapplication of Ps. 45 to reinforce role of other sheep.
Article 3: Stick with the Organization to get God's protection.
Article 4: Reinforcing the false doctrine that other sheep are not God's children.
w14 3/15 (May 5 - June 1)
THEMES: Make sacrifices. Do not doubt Governing Body. Provide for the Elderly and full-timers.
Article 1: Be self-sacrificing.
Article 2: Do not doubt nor be discouraged by failed expectations.
Article 3: Provide for elderly, but help full-timers avoid this duty.
Article 4: More instruction on helping the elderly.
w14 4/15 (June 2 - July 6)
THEMES: Make sacrifices. Rely on the Organization. Be obedient.
Article 1: Trust Jehovah to help you fulfill theocratic (i.e., organization) assignments.
Article 2: The end is near. Engage in JW preaching work zealously.
Article 3: Emigration to provide a better standard of living for your family is bad.
Article 4: Be willing to sacrifice creature comforts for the sake of the JW preaching work.
Article 5: Jehovah cares for and corrects us through his Organization.
w14 5/15 (July 7 - August 3)
THEMES: Good manners in JW preaching. Believe in, obey and support the Organization.
Article 1: How to respond to questions in the field ministry.
Article 2: Instructions on good manners for the JW field ministry.
Article 3: Jehovah only provides guidance to his people via an earthly organization.
Article 4: Our survival depends on obeying, being loyal to, and not doubting the Organization.
w14 6/15 (August 4 - August 31)
THEMES: Love God, obey the Organization. Show neighborly love throw the field ministry. Do not judge others. Encourage others to do more in the Organization.
Article 1: Love Jehovah and obey the Organization.
Article 2: Love our neighbors and show that love by preaching to them.
Article 3: Imitate Jehovah's mercy in dealing with the weaknesses of others.
Article 4: Encourage others, young ones particularly, to reach out for greater ‘privileges’ in the Organization.
W14 7/15 (September 1 – September 28)
THEMES: Beware of apostates. We are the true Organization of God.
Article 1: There may be apostates among us, but these can’t hide from Jehovah.
Article 2: Those who disagree with the Governing Body are rebellious apostates like Korah.
Article 3: An attempt to scripturally justify our name, Jehovah’s Witnesses, while dismissing the scripturally appropriate name, Witnesses of Jesus.
Article 4: We are the Organization Jehovah has chosen to bear witness to this name.
W14 8/15 (September 29 – October 26)
THEMES: JW Preaching. Two-class system of salvation. Obey Governing Body or die.
Article 1: Women are a preaching force.
Article 2: Instruction on preaching with tracts.
Article 3: Separating the other sheep (God’s friends) from the anointed (His sons).
Article 4: Our everlasting life depends on obeying the Governing Body.
W14 9/15 (October 27 – November 30)
THEMES: We are the true Organization of God. Inculcate that belief in young ones. Hope for other sheep. Support full-time Organization appointees.
Article 1: Our Organization has the truth.
Article 2: We are God’s Organization because we are persecuted.
Article 3: Parents encouraged to train children to believe in the Organization.
Article 4: The other sheep are to look forward to life on earth.
Article 5: Support the Organization’s Bethelites, pioneers and missionaries.
W14 10/15 (December 1 – December 28)
THEMES: Support anointed. Support and stay inside the Organization.
Article 1: The Bible Covenants are used to prove the role of the anointed over the other sheep.
Article 2: Our salvation depends on our support for the anointed, particularly the Governing Body.
Article 3: Support the Organization’s construction program through financial and work donations.
Article 4: Keep separate from the world, avoid materialism, and engage yet more in JW preaching work.
Our Spiritual Diet
Let us begin by working under the assumption that everything the weekly Watchtower study has taught us is scripturally accurate; that we are in Jehovah’s one true earthly organization and that he has appointed the men making up the Governing Body as the faithful and discreet slave designated to feed us food at the proper time. Based on that, how does our diet measure up to the aforementioned claim that it is ‘an abundant feast of rich spiritual food’?
The Apostle Paul is our guide in finding that answer to that question. He wrote:
“. . .For everyone who continues to feed on milk is unacquainted with the word of righteousness, for he is a young child. 14 But solid food belongs to mature people, to those who through use have their powers of discernment trained to distinguish both right and wrong.” (Heb 5:13, 14)
So the Hebrews were not eating solid food, let alone a feast. Instead they were consuming spiritual milk and food for children. What food? He continues:
“. . .For this reason, now that we have left the primary doctrine about the Christ, let us press on to maturity, not laying a foundation again, namely, (1) repentance from dead works, and (2) faith toward God, (3) the teaching on baptisms and the laying on of the hands, (4) the resurrection of the dead and everlasting judgment.” (Heb 6:1,2)
He lists four things that qualify as the milk of the word. Now to our diet. Here is a month-by-month summary of the food we’ve been consuming for the past year.
January: Be obedient to our leadership because Armageddon is close.
February: Don't doubt the Governing Body. Avoid apostates. Make sacrifices. You are not to partake.
March: Don't doubt the Governing Body. We are in the last days. The end is near. Make sacrifices.
April: We are special. It's good to be one of the other sheep. Stick to the Organization.
May: Make sacrifices. Do not doubt Governing Body. Provide for the Elderly and full-timers.
June: Make sacrifices. Rely on the Organization. Be obedient.
July: Good manners in JW preaching. Believe in, obey and support the Organization.
August: Love God, obey the Organization. Show neighborly love throw the field ministry. Do not judge others. Encourage others to do more in the Organization.
September: Beware of apostates. We are the true Organization of God.
October: JW Preaching. Two-class system of salvation. Obey Governing Body or die.
November: We are the true Organization of God. Inculcate that belief in young ones. Hope for other sheep. Support full-time Organization appointees.
December: Support anointed. Support and stay inside the Organization.
Converting this into a yearly summary, we end up with [numbers relate to Hebrews 6:1,2:
Stay free from the world and its works. (1)
Salvation depends on staying in the organization and not doubting but obeying the Governing Body. (2)
We must be self-sacrificing and make the JW door-to-door witnessing our main goal. The little flock of anointed has a special status. The rest of us are less privileged as other sheep who must support them. (3)
The end is near. The other sheep should hope for an earthly resurrection. (4)
It is not much of a stretch to see how these topics match up to the themes Paul exposes as the fundamental things, likened to the milk of the word. It should be evident from this that for the past year the food at the proper time has consisted not of a rich and varied bounty of nutritious food for mature people, but rather the milk and porridge intended for children.
It Gets Worse
The foregoing conclusion would be bad enough if it stopped there, but recall, we have been working on the premise that everything in the past year’s articles is scripturally accurate. Regular readers of the weekly Watchtower review will attest that this is simply not the case.
“. . .This is so that their hearts may be comforted and that they may be harmoniously joined together in love and may have all the riches that result from the full assurance of their understanding, in order to gain an accurate knowledge of the sacred secret of God, namely, Christ. 3 Carefully concealed in him are all the treasures of wisdom and of knowledge. 4 I am saying this so that no one may delude you with persuasive arguments. 5 Though I am absent in body, I am with you in spirit, rejoicing to see your good order and the firmness of your faith in Christ.” (Col 2:2-5)
If we realize that “all the treasures of wisdom and of knowledge” are concealed in Jesus Christ, we will not be deluded by persuasive arguments. Have we been deluded by persuasive arguments? If certain ones wanted to delude us persuasively, it follows that they would avoid talking much about Jesus, for in him are to be found both wisdom and knowledge. From the summary, it is clear that over the past year—52 hours of Watchtower studies—there has not been a single topic devoted to revealing the Christ. How can we repeatedly devote articles to knowledge about and devotion to the Governing Body and the Organization—neither entity mentioned even once in Scripture—while virtually ignoring the one who is central to the Christian faith? Are we not called "Christians" for a reason? Is salvation to be found in someone else? An Organization for example? If not, why have we beat the same drum over and over for the past year telling our brothers to obey the Governing Body and the Organization because their everlasting life depends on it? Why is the overriding theme for the year 2014 the Organization? Everything is viewed with that slant in mind. Even when dealing with preaching, we focus on publicizing our literature and web site while sidelining use of the Bible. We are actually told not to show the Bible on a street witnessing displays!
If we truly are enjoying a rich and abundant spiritual feast, why not a single article on even one of the fruits of the spirit? These are qualities that a mature Christian must develop. We barely touched on love and faith and in each instance, the topic was directed toward love for and faith in the Organization.
Healthy Nourishment or Junk Food.
One can live for some time on junk food. But those whose diet consists of it exclusively suffer ill health, pasty skin, obesity, premature aging, and early death. Nevertheless, it does fill the stomach and satisfy the appetite. This past year’s spiritual diet is typical fare for Jehovah’s Witnesses. We may leave feeling full and satiated, but we have not been nourished. Often, we have been taught falsehoods, as we’ve repeatedly proven from Scripture in our weekly reviews.
How many realize this? How many have come to love the Junk Food? Paul warned Timothy of the eventual predominance of such ones. (2 Timothy 3:3, 4) Evidence of this can be seen when some, recognizing how truly poor our current fare is, have demonstrated the courage to speak up. Time and again they are rebuked, shunned, and even persecuted. In a state of spiritual denial, many prefer to continue consuming their unwholesome and repetitive rations and punish anyone who might disturb their blissful state of ignorance.
It seems the only source open to us for healthy nutrition is the good, old-fashioned home cooked variety. Fortunately, the source of all nourishment has provided abundantly for us. Let us therefore feast daily on the manna from heaven found in God’s inspired Word.
Archived Comments
We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.
Comment by Joel on 2014-12-22 07:08:30
"It seems the only source open to us for healthy nutrition is the good, old-fashioned home cooked variety."
That is a very nice way of summing up non-denominational :)
Comment by kev c on 2014-12-22 07:23:33
Thanks for the review meleti .its interesting that the same old themes are being force fed the brothers . they are like the old LPs that get stuck in a groove . I remember back in the 90s i used to enjoy some of the studies we did . Although looking back they werent perfect . But i noticed it seemed to go down hill in the noughties i remember complaining to a couple of other elders about the content . That they were getting on my nerves always going on about dress and grooming . The answer i got was that that just shows how important it is .??????????? I remember thinking of 1 samuel 16 v7 and james 2 . As for the watchtower now im sure someone in the organisation is familiar with Robert J Lifton and his theories . Thanks kev
Reply by Meleti Vivlon on 2014-12-22 07:46:08
Thanks for that reference to Robert Jay Lifton's work. It is shocking how closely we parallel all his thought control identification markers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Jay_Lifton
Comment by BeenMislead on 2014-12-22 09:11:02
Wow! Thanks for the review Meleti.
I knew that they harped on Obey the GB, because if you don't you are going to die at Armageddon, which is coming Soon.
But it is really sobering and sad to see it summarized for the year.
It is so true, there was little to nothing about Jesus.
Comment by on 2014-12-22 11:20:03
Thanks, meleti, for the interesting break down of the articles. It seems Jesus has become an incidental by-product of the GB's arrogance. In yesterday's WT study the theme never focused on Jesus as the one who is taking in the lead in the preaching work. Yet , the friends gave all praise to Jehovah and the organization. Warwick is "sacred service", the article commented. I get so angry sometimes at the adulation given to the GB at the expense of seeing our wondweful and loving our leader Christ is. Sometimes I don't comment during the study and afterwards the brothers will ask me why I didn't. I simply tell them the article didn't make scriptual sense to me, or that it was slinging hash, and I don't like hash.
Comment by on 2014-12-22 11:32:02
It's amazing how many of the friends weren't able to understand that many of the things mentioned in yesterday's WT study were corporate changes disguised as, "Jehovah's direction"-merges, downsizing, lay-offs. I wonder which one of the GB personally heard the voice of God, (as Noah and Moses did), telling him to......"build Warwick". That's really keeping their eyes on the "things above", isn't it!
Comment by on 2014-12-22 11:46:45
And honestly, Meleti, how much meat can there be in a WT study article when we're given the question, the answer, and the scriptures, with no room for anything else. Don't even dare mention a point that's not in the paragraph or you may receive counsel after the meeting.
Comment by Christian on 2014-12-22 14:58:45
There is meat at the meetings Anonymous!...... They're those stringy bits of hard flesh that are clinging to the bones of a dried up carcass :)
Comment by on 2014-12-22 15:31:03
Hmmm, spiritual beef jerky, eh, Christian!
Comment by menrov on 2014-12-23 10:25:37
Again, as usual, well done. Much appreciated. It is most peculiar. Most JW's will say they are so "privileged" with the amount of food.And indeed, noting wrong with the amount. It is the contents that is the problem. Now that I no longer participate / visit / join meetings, I noticed that not one JW ever tells me that he/she learned so much, that their knowledge has increased etc. It is always more of the same....a person that suffering from insufficient or malnutrition, often has a swollen belly.
It looks full but the opposite is true.
Comment by search4truth on 2014-12-23 19:54:33
Spot on recapitulation, but I'm afraid that Jw's diet is't going to improve anytime soon. This diet is pushed on Jw intentionally and it's my believe something more sinister then mere delusion is behind this.
Comment by InNeedOfGrace on 2014-12-24 10:43:45
The best education any JW gets, is the "my book of bible stories" as a kid & the weekly bible reading program. These things have shaped me and my love for Jehovah, I have long been on a spiritual diet cutting out reading a lot of the materials they print. It's funny how similar it is to a real diet.
Once you abstained for a long period and start eating something again, you are finding it has a different taste. Similarly, some of the things I just glossed over, I am looking at right now and am thinking WOW did they just say that. I am still amazed that not more people can see how boring and repetitive these WT studies have been, very rarely these days do I walk out refreshed.
Comment by Imgonaburn on 2015-01-04 12:43:14
It's sad that the congregations are just being spoon fed the porridge of 'stick to the organisation' 'don't listen to apostates' and 'Armageddon is coming'
What about love your brothers and sisters, be kind to family, support the weak and don't judge one another. Speaking of porridge I found the whole situation 'gruelling' so I fell away about 3 years ago. However, as half of my immediate family still attend I have to be unbelievably careful in what I say so that I don't get tagged as an apostate! I'm still being 'controlled' even though I've left because I don't want to be dfd. My family can't believe that I'm happy as they're told it's impossible to be so when we are estranged from Jehovah. I've lost the love I once had and that is grievous to my heart as I still love God. Maybe one day I will find Him again, but I can't go back to jws.Reply by Wild Olive on 2015-03-16 07:09:23
Isn't it sad that Jesus has become an appendage inWT teaching,given enough time I think the same will happen to Jehovah,it will all be the GB and the organization,that will be the only reality in a JWs life,I could be wrong,but that feels like the trend.
Comment by WT Study: We Must Be Holy in All Our Conduct | Beroean Pickets on 2015-01-12 18:03:51
[…] on an analysis of all the Watchtower articles studied during the year of 2014, the milk of the word referred to at […]
Comment by Preaching Hate | Beroean Pickets on 2015-11-19 08:01:58
[…] as a vehicle for salvation, and obedience to the organization is a form of baya’a (allegiance). A review of the Watchtower studies of 2014 shows that the most important thing for a Jehovah’s Witness today is obedience and sacrifice to […]