Alternative Highlights – Hosea Chapters 8-14
Hosea 8:1-4
“Put a horn to your mouth! One comes like an eagle against the house of Jehovah, For they have violated my covenant and transgressed against my law. (Hosea 8:1)
The Organization has transgressed His law and shown disregard for His new covenant by teaching millions that they should not partake of the emblems at the annual memorial of Christ's death in direct contradiction to Christ’s instruction to "keep doing this in remembrance of me". (Luke 22:14-22, 1 Corinthians 15:26)
"To me they cry out, ‘My God, we, Israel, know you!’ 3 Israel has rejected what is good. Let an enemy pursue him. 4 They have appointed kings, but not through me." (Hosea 8:2-4a)
In July 15,2013 Watchtower, the Governing Body appointed themselves as the only faithful and discreet slave, but provided no proof that this was from Jehovah. Furthermore, they have admitted they are not inspired, yet they require Witnesses to obey even direction which may seem strange. Absolute obedience is what one gives to God or to a King, like Jesus Christ.
"They have appointed princes, but I did not recognize them." (Hosea 8:4b)
How will Jesus look upon anyone who presumptuously names themselves God's appointed channel when he returns. (See Geoffrey Jackson testimony before the ARC.)
With their silver and their gold they have made idols, To their own destruction.” (Ho 8:4c)
With their silver and gold, the organization has made built up a worldwide real estate empire comprising tens of thousand of Kingdom Halls, and over 500 Assembly Halls, the exclusive ownership of which it seized in 2012.
Hosea 12:6-7
““So return to your God, Maintain loyal love and justice, And always hope in your God. 7 But in the hand of the tradesman are deceptive scales; He loves to defraud.” (Ho 12:6, 7)
Do you find that there is justice when you ask them for clarification on a teaching or express doubt in their Scriptural reasoning. Do we hear praise from victims of child abuse in country after country for the just way in which they were treated? Is the Organization putting their hope in Jesus Christ when he is barely mentioned, but what takes precedence are articles and videos about construction of properties.
Hosea 14:9
“Who is wise? Let him understand these things. Who is discreet? Let him know them. For the ways of Jehovah are upright, And the righteous will walk in them; But the transgressors will stumble in them.” (Ho 14:9)
The one who is wise and discreet is the one who understands his ways have been wrong and strives to follow Jehovah’s upright ways. Is it wise or discreet to refuse to acknowledge wrongdoing or mistakes and rectify them? Surely, failure to do so will result in stumbling.
Live to Praise Jehovah! – Video: Use Your Talent for Jehovah.
Once again, good scriptural counsel is tainted by a video showing someone who was tempted into unchristian behaviour by an unusual set of circumstances. We have to ask how many brothers and sisters have ever been encouraged to accept such contracts as the brother in the experience? Does accepting a good contract or job offer inevitably lead down the path that this brother found himself on? Of course not. It is like the situation, accepting one drink of alcohol. Does that always lead to one becoming drunk? Hardly. Nevertheless, the implication in the video is that to accept any good job or contract offer will lead to immorality, drunkenness, etc, etc.
The discussion asks the question, "What are my spiritual goals?" Should not our response be: "To get to know Jehovah God and his son Christ Jesus better, and improve in our practice of the fruits of the spirit."
However, the encouragement from the platform and the majority of comments will reflect a desire to partake in the JW Spiritual Goals Ponzi Pyramid scheme.
The steps in the JW Spiritual Goals Ponzi Pyramid scheme are as follows: (See how many are mentioned in the meeting; total up the points awarded for fun.)
- Don’t pursue Higher Education
Even if you have an interest, or the skill, or the circumstances, do not pursue Higher Education. (Instead make yourself virtually unemployable, especially in a recession. – 1 point) - Obtain a Low Paying, Brain Numbing Job.
Instead of getting a secular job that will ensure you can support yourself and a potential family, you will only be able to get a boring, low-paying job. This will increase your hunger to get the ‘riches’ held out in the JW Spiritual Goals Ponzi Pyramid scheme—and your dependency on it. (No satisfying, well paid job required. - 1 point) - Auxiliary Pioneering
With what little spare time you now have, you will be strongly encouraged to use it to get to the 2nd rung on the ladder: an auxiliary pioneer. (You can now feel you are better and more important than the common publisher - 2 points.) - Regular Pioneering
Having enjoyed the spiritual benefits of auxiliary pioneering (the kudos associated with being known as an auxiliary pioneer) become a regular pioneer. (This gives you even more kudos in the congregation. - 3 points. And it almost guarantees an interview at the circuit assembly - 3 bonus points.) - LDC (ex-RBC) volunteer
Spend your small amount of spare time offering your labour and skills for free to the Organization to assist it in building Kingdom Halls, Assembly Halls, and Branch facilities. - 4 points. (For these then to be sold as surplus to requirements at vast profit with all monies absorbed by the unaccountable branch/headquarters) - Ministerial Servant
Following this path gives the brothers the necessary points to assist them in gaining an appointment to serve the congregation—the elders really—as a ministerial servant. (4 points). It also dramatically increases the brother’s eligibility as a marriage mate for all the pioneer sisters. (This is regardless of how many fruits of the Holy Spirit he displays or how old he is.) - Elder
By volunteering to assist elderly ones and lead field service arrangements (all the ones the elders find inconvenient to lead), a brother can get extra bonus points to aid him in a rapid appointment (promotion) to the responsibilities (authority) of an elder (5 points). - Serving Where the Need Is Greater
Move to a foreign language congregation, or abroad. (5 points) - Further ‘Privileges’
At stage 6 or 7, a brother can then apply for the special schools (5 points per school) such as MTS, or School for Christian Couples (if married) to gain extra points towards the ultimate goal (prestigious prize) of Bethel service (10 points) or Circuit work (50 points).
Special bonus points awarded by us for mention of the following Non-JW Spiritual Goals. Sadly not by the organization.
- ‘relief ministry’ (500 points)
- ‘shepherding ministry’ (500 points)
- ‘personal hospitality’ (500 points)
- ‘assisting widows and orphans in their tribulation’ (1000 points).
Congregation Book Study (kr chap. 20 para 7-16)
Paragraph 12 emphasizes that our relief ministry helps "afflicted ones get back into their spiritual routine." Yet the cited scripture in support of this, 2 Corinthians 1:3,4, talks about "comforting others in any sort of trial". People undergoing stressful trials such as a natural disaster or loss of a loved one, need and want comforting, not to be pushed into evangelising with the stress it entails. Further, if those around the brothers are also suffering, they will not be in a mental state to appreciate any spiritual routine; they need practical help first and for some time.
Paragraph 14 cites Romans 1:11, 12 and Romans 12:12 in support of restarting meeting attendance immediately; yet Romans 1:11,12 talks about interchange of encouragement. However the meetings arranged by the organization are mainly talks, and even the Congregation Book Study or Watchtower Study allow little time to comment and encourage on anything other than the paragraph contents. There is even less time to talk to one another to encourage each other after the long meeting.
Yes, ‘relief ministry’ is important, but it should be done with the aim of assisting ones to ‘get back on their feet’ as the saying goes, and encourage them, thereby showing our love and concern, not with the ulterior motive of getting ones back at the meetings and out preaching as soon as possible.
Archived Comments
We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.
Comment by Pekanman on 2017-10-25 16:09:50
Wow that was wonderful. Very nice job. Congratulations. It's is so true that the kudos awarded when pioneering are big. When I stopped a couple years ago that evaporated quickly though.oh well. I actually just wrote a letter a couple weeks ago asking to have all my privileges removed. Hard to support an organization that is complicit in the things they are. Keep up the great work, this builds my faith in Jehovah and Jesus and not in an organization that teaches salvation comes through them and not the Christ.
Reply by Warp Speed on 2017-10-25 17:02:41
Hi Pekanman,
Nice to hear from you on this forum. There are many of us here that have relinquished their "privileges" recently as well. It sure is a blessing to be able to have an up building and encouraging exchange here on BP.
Keep the faith,
WSReply by Pekanman on 2017-10-25 17:10:22
Thank you. I have been reading for a month or so after finding this great site and so much makes sense here. I thought for a long time I was the only one with thoughts like these. Yes evil thinking for ourselves kind of thoughts. Nice to meet you and know that like minded ones are here to love and support each other. John 13:35
Reply by Devora on 2017-10-28 17:00:17
Pekanman,welcome..am a newbie here,too..& thank Jah and Christ for also finding our spiritual family here.What You'd said about our sincere
questions-then- actively seeking to confirm truth vs.falsehoods..Yes,I too(as probably so many others here)felt real fear..asking YHWH was I being'evil'just as You'd said;my heart would pound;I'd be sweating,and so fearful(at the local public libraries with computers)the first year..looking at the doorway for any of my fellow JW's to walk in?(It did happen twice but I'd quickly switched to another webpage)..Growing in the deepest and most revealing personal study('apostasy'no 'independent'study!)I found the Bible's correct & satisfying answers;rejoiced,but was missing my true Brotherhood..not anymore!Daily I'm thankful for these brothers and sister's insights..what a Beautiful Site,meaning,it is a reflection of the composite-yes tho in progress-of the body of Christ.And Love is the cement,yes..
Reply by MarthaMartha on 2017-10-26 03:57:23
Welcome Pekanman. ?
I was in the same 'place' a few years ago and found the same reassurance and support here. They're a lovely bunch. ?
It is a great site, quite unique I think, and full of food for thought.
It's lovely to see new people here, and read all our experiences and thoughts. I hope you feel comfortable here!
MMReply by Pekanman on 2017-10-26 09:07:32
Thanks for the welcome. So much to read and learn here. And appreciate the like minded ones here who are seeing that the spiritual food being given to the congregations is not what it is supposed to be. Especially with the simplifying of everything so no thinking is required. Not exactly solid food is it? Barely milk. Heb 5:12,13.
Reply by Tadua on 2017-10-26 09:51:06
A warm Welcome pekanman
And to all other spiritually hungry ones. When we find the FDS is failing to serve up even watered down milk, then we have to feed ourselves and help all those we can. All of us spiritually hungry ones, love Jehovah our father and Jesus our mediator and want to continue learning how to please them. Welcome to the journey. We are all on it together.Reply by Devora on 2017-10-28 15:03:31
Tadua,you nailed it!with 100% great satisfaction to see how you used Hosea and other Scriptures so skillfully to slam them...if they keep persisting in all their counterfeit form of Christianity(until our Lord's sudden coming)there will be no mercy,as Christ/the Scriptures say...How ironic:when their drumbeats sound-out each week in more fake veerings;harsh,unloving,hypocritical,pharasiacal"etc"and the poor flock just keeps 'jumping to the gb/wt beats'...they're being'beat'en.Sounds funny but really sad.I keep praying daily that more and more "Come Out". Conversely,our feeding here & mutual encouragements,as a freed group,is on the solid deep truths of God's Word;our focus on Christ...Joy!
Reply by Meleti Vivlon on 2017-10-26 09:59:31
It's good to have you with us, Pekaman
Reply by Phelps on 2017-10-27 10:46:22
Hola querido hermano Pekanman;das en un punto muy importante :todos hemos entregado nuestras conciencias a la watchtower,siempre hicimos preguntas en secreto pero por miedo o por sostener nuestro puesto de autoridad,preferimos el silencio.requiere mucho valor dejar nuestra ficticia autoridad y dedicarnos a seguir a cristo y a nuestro padre celestial.eres un ejemplo más...Gracias
Comment by Maxwell on 2017-10-25 22:01:42
Ministerial Training School (MTS) and School for Christian Couples have both been replaced by the School For Kingdom Evangelizers. Pioneers between the ages of 23 and 65 can apply regardless of sex or marital status. (Further details can be found in the Kingdom Rules book on page 189.)
Reply by MarthaMartha on 2017-10-26 03:48:51
True.
In beteen the old MTS and the current SKE, wasn't it BSSB ( Bible school for Single Brothers) and the BSCC ( Bible School for Christian Couples)?
??
Who comes up with all these names and the resulting acronyms? And why? I'm sure it's to identify those who are not 'keeping up with present truth and refinements'. ?
Of course if you don't know the latest acronyms, it's evidence of a lack of spiritual appreciation. At least I can claim age and confusion. I have endured almost 6 decades of the latest good ideas and their associated acronyms.
As for me, I'm in the school of FUTTBT.
( Fed Up To The Back Teeth)
??
Reply by Tadua on 2017-10-26 05:00:46
Well spotted Maxwell. It’s difficult at times to mentally keep up with the pace of change within the organisation at times. Still it would be interesting to see how many others make mention of the old schools like I did. I also wonder how many are aware that Gilead school is only for Bethelites and C.O’s now.
Reply by Maxwell on 2017-10-26 08:19:36
Funny you should say that. Just this week an elder mentioned MTS as an opportunity for brothers FROM THE PLATFORM!
Comment by Amitafal on 2017-10-26 02:27:09
Well done. I look forward to your articles. Both Meleti and yourself write interesting and encouraging articles- the sort WT should be giving at meetings. However as they are not God’s organisation and the governing body are not the FDS but more concerned in Real Estate, how could they possibly write anything of spiritual value.
Comment by Worldling on 2017-10-26 10:48:03
When a corporation registers their name in all capitol letters with the U.S. fed-a-rule government which is how the WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA and the WATCHTOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF NEW YORK INC. are registered that means that they are owned by the government. If you think they being part of the U.N. was something big you haven't seen nothing yet.Lu 4:6. I challenge anyone to research it and prove me wrong!
Comment by Phelps on 2017-10-27 10:49:04
Sencillamente un artículo excelente....Como todos...trato de encontrar algún algún error en lo que escribes meleti.pero no he logrado ?...Con mucho cariño