James Penton speaks about the origins of the teachings of Jehovah's Witnesses

– posted by J_Penton
Witnesses are taught that Charles Taze Russell originated all the teachings that make Jehovah's Witnesses stand out from the other religions in Christendom. This turns out to be untrue. In fact, it will surprise most Witnesses to learn that their millenarian teachings come from a Catholic priest, a Jesuit no less. James Penton, a Canadian history professor and author of several scholarly books on Jehovah's Witnesses takes us back three centuries to the origin of many of the doctrines Witnesses mistakenly believe are theirs alone.

[embed]https://youtu.be/cuZMD4Uzn7M[/embed]

Archived Comments

We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.

  • Comment by Leonardo Josephus on 2019-12-28 12:09:46

    Hi Eric. Thanks so much for arranging this. All the background stuff is so helpful. Interesting to note the connection to the Plymouth Brethren, which I was totally unaware of.
    Thanks for the Aldbury Park link too.
    A lot about Russell was what I had concluded, namely that he hi-jacked ideas from others.
    Am I right that much of this information is in James Penton's book ?

    • Reply by Meleti Vivlon on 2020-01-09 13:34:46

      That's correct. It's in Apocalypse Delayed

  • Comment by Chet on 2019-12-30 11:51:09

    Great information. What I find most interesting is that many religions are now finding their teachings scrutinized as the Internet makes information more readily available.

    It’s obvious that the Witnesses are not what they would claim to be. Their origins are not nearly so concise as they would have us believe. There’s nothing surprising about this. The 18th and 19th centuries were a time when many religious speculations were born and all sorts of new ideas came to light. I don’t think of this as bad, in and of itself, because people were resisting the hegemony of the religious establishment and paving the way for reform.

    The bad part is when people decide that these new movements should be followed without question. I can see no evidence that God is behind any of these movements. What is good, is that people are questioning and striving to see beyond the traditions of men.

Recent content

Hello everyone, and welcome back to the channel.Today we’re going to examine one of the most frequently cited Trinitarian proof texts—Colossians 2:9. Many believe this verse definitively proves that Jesus is God Almighty…

Hello everyone, welcome back.Today we’re going to look carefully at Hebrews 1:8–10, a passage many consider one of the strongest proofs that Jesus is God Almighty.Let’s read the text:But to the Son He says:“Your throne,…

In the beginning, the physical realm and the spiritual realm overlapped. Our Heavenly Father created humans, both male and female, and like every caring father, he spent time with his children. In the opening chapters of…

The next common proof text Trinitarians use is John 8:58.Of all the verses that have been presented to me over the years, this one, in my view, demonstrates just how far some are willing to go in order to secure…

There is a new Governing Body update released today that reverses a policy dating way back to when I was a young man. In Governing Body Update #2, Gerrit Lösch informed Jehovah’s Witnesses that the longstanding…

I like to collect different translations of the Bible. Recently I bought this [hold up book] which is the New Testament translation by the Eastern Greek Orthodox church. Like the Western Roman Catholic church, the…