[this article was contributed by Alex Rover]
[caption id="attachment_2619" align="aligncenter" width="658"]
![Esau [right] selling his birthright to Jacob or the Lentil Stew, 17th Century, Public Domain, Matthias Stom](http://meletivivlon.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/matthias_stomer_umkreis_das_linsengericht.jpg?w=300)
Esau [right] selling his birthright to Jacob or the Lentil Stew, 17th Century, Public Domain, Matthias Stom[/caption]Jacob and Esau were twins born to Isaac, the son of Abraham. Isaac was the child of promise (Ga 4:28) through which God’s covenant would be passed down. Now Esau and Jacob struggled in the womb, but Jehovah told Rebecca the older would serve the younger (Ge 25:23). Esau came to be the firstborn and heir to the promise. Tragically, he despised his birthright (Ge 25:29-34) over some bread and lentil stew.Thus Jacob became the child of promise, not the firstborn Esau. According to the flesh, neither are we, but as Paul wrote: Christians are ‘born according to the Spirit’ (Ga 4:29, 31).
“In other words, it is not the children by physical descent who are God’s children, but it is the children of the promise who are regarded as Abraham’s offspring.” – Ro 9:8 NIV
We can observe Paul here mentions but one inheritance. With a single inheritance, one stands to either gain or lose it: the inheritance of the firstborn.
Jacob valued his inheritance
Jacob was not the firstborn in physical sense, but he became the child of promise and heir to the covenant when Esau sold off his right. Much later, gentiles were called to become children of the promise. Just like Jacob, they had no physical birthright to claim an inheritance, but they were firstfruits in the spiritual sense.
The Jacob-like children of promise are those who have accepted “the word of truth”; “the gospel of their salvation”. Those who “hoped in Christ”, “the mediator of the new covenant” and thus 'obtained an inheritance'.
“Therefore he is the mediator of the new covenant, so that those who are called may receive the promised eternal inheritance, since a death has occurred that redeems them from the transgressions committed under the first covenant.” – He 9:15 ESV
“In him we have obtained an inheritance, having been predestined according to the purpose of him who works all things according to the counsel of his will, so that we were the first to hope in Christ might be to the praise of his glory. In him you will also, when you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in him, were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, who is the guarantee of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it, to the praise of his glory.” – Ep 1:11-13 ESV
The Scriptures call these people ‘Christianos’ – a Greek word derived from ‘christos’ or Christ, which means ‘anointed one’ (Ac 11:16, Ac 26:28, 1 Pe 4:16).
Once we obtain this promise, "let us continue to hold firmly to the hope that we confess without wavering" (He 10:23). This way we prove to be like Jacob, valuing our spiritual inheritance.
Esau set his heart to treasures on earth
Based on what we know about Esau, he had the prospect of inheritance, but valued that which was physical or earthly more than that which was spiritual. And eventually he surrendered his spiritual inheritance for what he valued more.
Jesus Christ had a few things to say about valuing the spiritual more than the physical:
“Jesus said to him, “If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow me.” – Mt 19:21 NKJV
“Do not accumulate for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal. But accumulate for yourselves treasures in heaven, where moth and rust do not destroy, and thieves do not break in and steal. For where you treasure is, there your heart will be also.” – Mt 6: 19-21 NKJV
There was no middle ground for the young man. He needed to make a choice whether he valued the Spiritual over the Physical. The subsequent verse (Mt 19:22) made his choice clear and identified himself as one with Esau's mentality, because he “left sorrowful” [i] - indicating that he valued the physical blessings over the spiritual.
[caption id="attachment_2655" align="aligncenter" width="364"]
Do treasures on earth outweigh the prospect of being with Christ in paradise? - Jesus Image by 'Waiting For The Word' via flickr.[/caption]The Watchtower Society Identifies an Esau Class
In 1935, J. F. Rutherford, president of Jehovah’s Witnesses gave the historic talk in which he declared “Behold! The Great Multitude!” referring to those who declared a preference to live forever on earth.
It recently came to my attention [ii] that The Watchtower Society likened the Great Crowd to the Prodigal Son. The WT of Nov 15, 1943 explains this group selfishly pursued their earthly privileges according to their will for a period after the Great Tribulation broke out after 1914.
Paragraph 25 plainly states that the Great Crowd wasted their inheritance:
By the Society's own admission, the Great Crowd thus parallels an Esau Class. This is the class comprised of those who squandered their spiritual inheritance for a portion on earth. They traded their heavenly hope for the prospect of eternal earthly and material blessings.
A Collapsed House
Brothers and Sisters, EXAMINE THE FOUNDATION for an earthly hope: if Christ did not stop calling Christians in 1935, and if the Great Tribulation did not start in 1914 and it did not get interrupted in 1919, then why give up your inheritance now that the Watchtower admits that the Tribulation is a future event?
“Everyone who hears these words of mine, and doesn't do them will be like a foolish man, who built his house on the sand. The rain came down, the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat on that house; and it fell— and great was its fall.” – Mt 7:26-27 WEB
Rain has come down on the teachings that excluded millions from their hope and winds are blowing.
The building remained for a long time, even as its foundation gradually weakened. Even after realizing the great tribulation did not occur in 1914, The Watchtower study article of 2/15/89, “When the Lost Son is Found”, stubbornly continued to identify the older son as the anointed who did not welcome back their young brother of the earthly class, who had squandered the inheritance:
“But who in modern times do the two sons represent? [...] The older son represents some members of the ‘little flock’ [...] they had no desire to welcome an earthly class, ‘the other sheep’”.
As recently as 2013, the Watchtower Society admitted that cracks appeared in their house until the position was no longer tenable:
“For a number of years, we thought that the great tribulation began in 1914. [..] There would be a beginning (1914-1918), the tribulation would be interrupted (from 1918 onward), and it would conclude at Armageddon. […] “We also discerned that the first part of the great tribulation did not begin in 1914.” – w13 7/15 p.3-5
With the annual meeting of 2014 and the subsequent Watchtower of 15 March, 2015, the Society is further distancing themselves from antitypes like the Prodigal Son understanding. But a house with a broken foundation cannot be restored. It needs to be torn down and replaced:
“Neither do people pour new wine into old wineskins. If they do, the skins will burst; the wine will run out and the wineskins will be ruined. No, they pour wine into new wineskins, and both are preserved.” – Mt 9:17
In effect, there is currently no doctrinal foundation left for the explanation of the Prodigal Son as it existed 70 years ago. Time has shown this to be a teaching that did not originate from Jehovah. The old wineskins have burst, and the wine is running out.
“There is one body and one Spirit, just as you also were called to one hope when you were called; one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all” – Eph 4:4-6
With the same vigor we teach that there is but one God, let us also defend that there is but one hope to which we are called. Remain in this teaching and your house will be built on a rock.
Who are the Meek whom will inherit the Earth?
The meek will inherit the earth (Mt 5:5), but the poor would also inherit the kingdom of heaven (Mt 5:3). Nobody can deny that while Jesus Christ inherits the earth, he is also described as ruling from heaven as its king. Likewise Christians do not deny the Scriptural guarantee of a new earth by striving toward the heavenly inheritance.
Additionally we know that in paradise earth, Christ’s bride will descend out of heaven toward earth. While we are not yet able to see how this will be fulfilled, Scripture states that God himself will be with mankind. Then who are we to say that a heavenly hope is not in harmony with a paradise earth?
“The holy city – the New Jerusalem – descending out of heaven from God, made ready like a bride adorned for her husband.” – Re 21:2 NET
“Look! The residence of God is among human beings. He will live among them, and they will be his people, and God himself will be with them.” – Re 21:3 NET
By illustration: a prince is promised to inherit his Father’s kingdom. The prince promised himself to a humble Shulamite maiden: one day he would return for her hand in marriage and she would inherit the land if she proved righteous and meek. Finally he returns and brings her to his palace, for a splendid wedding, and now the prince is a king. They inherit the land as king and queen. The new king wants to be hands-on because he loves his subjects, and together with his queen he walks the lands and so all the people of his kingdom are blessed (Ge 22:17-18).
The inheritance is for the children of the promise, the Bride of Christ. They are the meek and are declared righteous by Christ’s blood. The earth will be their possession, and they will find their delight serving alongside Christ for the benefit of mankind.
The Father’s plan is indeed to restore what was lost – a paradise earth – and bless all humanity through it!
Do not be like Esau!
Let us no longer live for yourselves, but for Christ. This is what Christ’s love for us compels us to do: if we are in Christ, then we are part of a new creation (2 Co 5:15-17). We boldly reject Satan’s offer for earthly pleasure and treasure and instead look forward to our Lord’s return as our hope:
“For the grace of God has appeared that offers salvation to all people. It teaches us to say ‘No’ to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age, while we wait for the blessed hope – the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all wickedness and to purify for himself a people that are his very own, eager to do what is good.” – Ti 2:11-14 NIV
Ever since Christ gave up his life for us in the greatest display of love, we belong to him and have the opportunity to be reconciled to our heavenly Father. The doors to this hope did not close in 1935, as the Governing Body has already admitted in the Question from Readers of WT 11/15 2007.
This door will remain open at least until the start of the Great Tribulation. Can you identify when is the acceptable time (Is 49:8)?
"And working together with Him, we also urge you not to receive the grace of God in vain – for he says, ‘AT THE ACCEPTABLE TIME I LISTENED TO YOU, AND ON THE DAY OF SALVATION I HELPED YOU.’ Behold, now is ‘THE ACCEPTABLE TIME,’ behind, now is “THE DAY OF SALVATION” – 2 Co 6:1-2
Will you receive God’s grace in vain? Scripture talks about a time when the faithful remnant will be gathered together from the four corners of the earth to meet their Lord the Christ in the clouds (Mark 13:27).
When that day comes, will you beat yourself in lamentation, realizing that you have squandered your inheritance to be with Christ? How would you feel if on that very day, you find yourself left behind?
“Two men will be in the field; one will be taken and the other left.” – Mt 24:40
Esau squandered his inheritance. Will you? We urge you to not to receive the grace of God in vain. Now is the acceptable time.
[i] We can also observe that Christ requested the young man to “follow him”. Interestingly, Revelation 14:4 describes the 144,000 as those “who follow the Lamb wherever he goes”. We can thus make a connection between the 144,000 and the Jacob Class.
[ii] Via an analysis on ad1914.com
Archived Comments
We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.
Comment by donotforgetus on 2015-01-15 13:00:34
Alex Rover, I am a little confused by your article. Are you saying you believe that what Paul wrote in Romans 9 applies also to the Great Crowd in Revelation?
(Romans 9:6-13) . . .However, it is not as though the word of God had failed. For not all who [spring] from Israel are really “Israel.” 7 Neither because they are Abraham’s seed are they all children, but: “What will be called ‘your seed’ will be through Isaac.” 8 That is, the children in the flesh are not really the children of God, but the children by the promise are counted as the seed. 9 For the word of promise was as follows: “At this time I will come and Sarah will have a son.” 10 Yet not that case alone, but also when Re·bek′ah conceived twins from the one [man], Isaac our forefather: 11 for when they had not yet been born nor had practiced anything good or vile, in order that the purpose of God respecting the choosing might continue dependent, not upon works, but upon the One who calls, 12 it was said to her: “The older will be the slave of the younger.” 13 Just as it is written: “I loved Jacob, but E′sau I hated.”
God knew even before Esau's birth that he would fail and Jacob would inherit the blessing. God knew the Jews, like Esau, would also fail but can that be applied to the Great Crowd as well?
On the other hand, if you are applying Hebrews 12 to those in the congregations who out of fear of men do not publicly partake then I agree.
(Hebrews 12:16, 17) . . .that there may be no fornicator nor anyone not appreciating sacred things, like E′sau, who in exchange for one meal gave away his rights as firstborn. 17 For YOU know that afterward also when he wanted to inherit the blessing he was rejected, for, although he earnestly sought a change of mind with tears, he found no place for it."
We cannot publicly turn our backs toward Jesus merely because we fear what others will say or do. We must stand up in the congregation and publicly declare our union with Christ. To do anything else is tantamount to spiritual cowardice for if we cannot stand with Christ before our brothers how could we have stood with Christ before the Jewish leaders who opposed him?
With respect,
LauraReply by Alex Rover on 2015-01-15 14:21:16
Hi Laura,
thank you for your comment. I'll be glad to clarify some things.
First on the Great Crowd. The article is from the perspective of a Jehovah's Witness, where the Society teaches the Great Crowd should not accept the inheritance. I demonstrate how they themselves used to teach that this was tantamount to squandering their hope.
I do personally think that the great crowd in heaven from Revelation are Christians, but "whos who" in Revelation is not the topic of this article. We are doing some really deep research on that topic though and when we feel confident to share our findings, you will see an article on that topic.
It's clear that all Christians should partake today, and by rejecting Christ's ransom personally we can be like Esau. The purpose of this article is to encourage all readers to value their inheritance by accepting Christ. Romans 9 applies to all Christians.
In relation to Hebrews 12, once we accept our inheritance, we wouldn't be like Esau and give it up again. But if we haven't accepted it yet while it is promised to us, we can be like Jacob and "firmly grab hold of it".
Now on the topic of partaking publicly, that's another topic all together, and given that some here partake privately and some publicly it is something we have to be sensitive about. Some of our visitors don't recognize the JW memorial. Saying you should partake of the Catholic Eucharist or you are a coward makes no sense. What matters is declaring our hope to others. It would be best this topic is handled on the forum or in another article.Reply by donotforgetus on 2015-01-15 17:05:00
Hi Alex, I was once a coward myself. If I have wounded some here that was not my intention and I apologize. I spoke from personal experience. I know how very hard it is to stand up and I know what it feels like to fail to stand up. The latter is far more painful!
I thought you were encouraging the brothers and sisters in the Kingdom Hall to accept Christ. If that is the case then should they not also partake of the emblems at the Kingdom Hall? I hope all who believe they are anointed will take up the bread and wine at the Kingdom Hall and let all see that Christ lives among us and in the hope that we will not be disowned for having publicly disowned him before men.
(Matthew 10:33) 33 "but whoever disowns me before men, I will also disown him before my Father who is in the heavens."
With respect and apology,
LauraReply by Alex Rover on 2015-01-15 17:27:32
Hi Laura, no need to apologize!
disowning Christ can come in many ways, and a most important aspect is not to be ashamed of our calling. If we for many years hide our calling then yes there may be a problem, but some of our readers feel like the societies' memorial is not valid, so they follow the command to partake, yet in more private settings. Jesus said he would be in our midst when just two or three are together. That doesn't mean they disown Christ. We must respect each other consciences in this matter.
Alex
Reply by donotforgetus on 2015-01-15 19:36:26
Alex, thank you for the kind reply. You said that some here do not believe the Memorial at the Kingdom Hall is valid. If this is so then those of us who partake at the Memorial do so invalidly. If that is the case then there is much sorrow among us because Jehovah may not recognize us as among the anointed. We toil in vain if we partake in an invalid Memorial of Christ's death.
I partake at the Kingdom Hall in what some believe is an invalid Memorial. Yet, Jehovah has given the anointed in the congregations increase.
With respect,
Laura
Reply by Alex Rover on 2015-01-15 20:23:51
Dear Laura,
it would be best if we saved this topic for another day since it might detract from the purpose of this article. I might suggest the article "Memorial Partakers 2014" to be a better place, since it already has a number of commentators suggesting as much. Alternatively, we could discuss it in depth on the discussthetruth.com forum, keeping in mind others.
In my article "Sacraments of Initiation" we discussed that partaking is an outward profession of our anointing. It is not the only way we declare Christ. Also, one does not become anointed because of partaking, and one does not lose his anointing because he is because of circumstances unable to do so. Finally we might choose to partake and declare Jesus any time, because we are not under the law to keep the Passover - but always with solemn dignity.
Also if the holy spirit in accordance with your conscience urges you to partake at the JW memorial, then let it be to a testimony and glory of our Lord Jesus Christ. No such profession is ever in vain.
We are not masters of anyone's faith here, and neither we are your judge. Each of us must act according to his conscience before Christ.
Your brother in Christ,
Alex Rover
Comment by kev c on 2015-01-15 16:04:03
Well done alex. The brothers and sisters need articles like this. I personally think your right when you say all christians should partake. A thorough examination of the christian scriptures show this to be the case. Matthew 26v27 I really don't believe there's any real. NT scriptural precedent that shows we don't need to partake. Some point to 1 corinthians 11 v 27 to 31. But its simply a warning. That we need to have the right attitude and appreciation. I think revelation 3 v 20 is interesting alex. LOOK. I am standing at the door knocking if anyone hears my voice and opens the door. I will come into his house and take the evening meal with him and he with me. I think there's some interesting phrases at phillipians 3 v 12 to 20. That may apply as well. Kev. C
Comment by kev c on 2015-01-16 05:04:43
Just picking up on the comments already on this blog. I think it tells us something about the religion and its teachers. When as we said we have many of the brothers who partake of the christ in private. And not openly in the congregation. Why is that. ? Why is it that anyone who partakes is viewed with suspicion and discouraged from doing so like I was. This is supposed to be the true christian congregation and the teachers are supposed to be. Leading us to christ not denying him. Ephesians 4 v 11 to 16. Why is it that many are fearful to partake in a christian congregation when its a command from christ himself to keep doing this in rememberance of me. We should not be in fear to partake among people who claim to be christians. But we are. !!! Why ?? I'm. Sorry but in my mind this can only mean one thing. Putting it very mildly there's something seriously wrong with this religion.
Comment by InNeedOfGrace on 2015-01-16 12:00:50
Maybe some day someone like me a year ago will find this page when they google for anointed jw in their quest to learn more about the topic. And maybe in part through articles such as these there will be a person like me who will be convicted that the little nudging they felt by the Holy Spirit was more then a little nudging, but actually God calling them to explore the hope which he set before them in scriptures.