[this article was contributed by Alex Rover]
We did not exist for an infinite amount of time. Then for a brief moment, we come into existence. Then we die, and we are reduced to nothing once more.
Each such moment starts with childhood. We learn to walk, we learn to speak and we discover new wonders every day. We enjoy forging our first friendships. We choose a skill and devote ourselves to becoming good at something. We fall in love. We desire a home, perhaps a family of our own. Then there is a point where we achieve those things and the dust settles.
I am in my twenties and I have perhaps fifty years left to live. I am in my fifties and have perhaps twenty or thirty years left to live. I am in my sixties and need to make every day count.
It varies from person to person depending how soon we reach our initial goals in life, but sooner or later it hits us like an ice cold shower. What is the meaning of my life?
Most of us are climbing the mountain hoping that on the top life will be great. But time and again we learn from highly successful people that the mountaintop only reveals the emptiness of life. We see many turn to charity to give their life meaning. Others fall into a destructive cycle that ends in death.
Jehovah taught us this lesson through Solomon. He allowed him to enjoy success by any measure possible, so that he could share with us the conclusion:
“Meaningless! Meaningless! [..] Utterly meaningless! Everything is meaningless!” – Ecclesiastes 1:2
This is the human condition. We have eternity planted in our spirit but are rooted in mortality through our flesh. This conflict has given rise to the belief in the immortality of the soul. This is what every religion has in common: hope after death. Whether it is through resurrection on earth, resurrection in heaven, reincarnation or a continuation of our soul in spirit, religion is the way mankind has historically dealt with the emptiness of life. We can simply not accept that this life is all there is.
The age of enlightenment has given rise to Atheists who accept their mortality. Yet through science they are not giving up their quest for continuation of life. Rejuvenating the body through stem cells, organ transplants or genetic modification, transferring their thoughts to a computer or freezing their bodies - truly, science creates another hope for continuation of life and proves to be just another way we cope with the human condition.
The Christian Perspective
What about us Christians? The resurrection of Jesus Christ is the single most important historical event to us. It’s not just a matter of faith, it’s a matter of evidence. If it happened, then we have evidence of our hope. If it didn’t happen then we are self-deluding.
And if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is meaningless and your faith is meaningless. – 1 Cor 15:14
Historic evidence is not conclusive about this. Some say that where there is fire, there must be smoke. But by the same reasoning, Joseph Smith and Muhammad also raised a large following, yet as Christians we don’t consider their accounts credible.
But one nagging truth remains:
If God has given us the power to think and reason, then wouldn’t it make sense he wants us to use it? We should thus reject double standards when examining information at our disposal.
The Inspired Scriptures
We can argue that because the Scriptures say Christ is risen, it must be true. After all, doesn’t 2 Timothy 3:16 state that “All Scripture is inspired by God”?
Alfred Barnes accepted that since the New Testament wasn’t canonized at the time the apostle wrote the above words, he could have made no reference to it. He said that his words “properly refer to the Old Testament, and should not be applied to any part of the New Testament, unless it can be shown that that part was then written, and was included under the general name of ‘the Scriptures’” [1]
Imagine I wrote a letter to Meleti and then say all Scripture is inspired. Would you think I was including my letter to Meleti in that statement? Of course not!
That does not mean we need to dismiss the New Testament as uninspired. The early Church Fathers accepted into the canon each writing on its own merit. And we ourselves can attest to the harmony between the Old and New Testament canon through our years of study.
At the time of writing of 2nd Timothy, several versions of the gospel were going around. Some were later classified as forgeries or apocryphal. Even the gospels that were considered canonical were not necessarily written by Christ’s apostles and most scholars agree they were penned down versions of oral accounts.
Internal discrepancies in the New Testament about the details surrounding his resurrection don’t make a good historical argument. Here are just a handful examples:
- What time did the women visit the tomb? At dawn (Mat 28:1), after sunrise (Mark 16:2) or when it was still dark (John 20:1).
- What was their purpose? To bring spices because they already had seen the tomb (Mark 15:47, Mark 16:1, Luke 23:55, Luke 24:1) or to go see the tomb (Matthew 28:1) or had the body already been spiced before they arrived (John 19:39-40)?
- Who was at the tomb when they arrived? One angel sitting on a stone (Matthew 28:1-7) or one young man sitting inside the tomb (Mark 16:4-5) or two men standing inside (Luke 24:2-4) or two angels sitting at each end of the bed (John 20:1-12)?
- Did the women tell others what happened? Some scriptures say yes, others say no. (Matthew 28:8, Mark 16:8)
- Who did Jesus first appear to after the woman? Eleven disciples (Mat 28:16), ten disciples (John 20:19-24), two disciples in Emmaus and then to eleven (Luke 24:13;12:36) or first to Peter and then the twelve (1Co 15:5)?
The next observation is an important one. Muslims and Mormons believe their holy writings were received without error directly from heaven. If in the Quran or writings of Joseph Smith there existed a contradiction, the entire work would be disqualified.
Not so with the Bible. Inspired doesn’t have to mean flawless. Literally, it means God-Breathed. An excellent Scripture that illustrates what this means can be found in Isaiah:
So shall my word be that goeth forth out of my mouth: it shall not return to me void, but it shall accomplish that which I please, and it shall prosper in the thing whereto I sent it. – Isaiah 55:11
To illustrate: God had a purpose for Adam, a God-breathed creature. Adam was not perfect, but did God accomplish filling the earth? Were the animals named? And what of his purpose for a paradise earth? Did the imperfection of this God-breathed person stand in the way of God accomplishing his purpose?
Christians don’t need the Bible to be a flawless record straight from angels in heaven for it to be inspired. We need Scripture to be in harmony; to prosper in the purpose for which God has given it to us. And what is that purpose according to 2 Timothy 3:16? Teaching, reproof, correction and training in righteousness. The Law and Old Testament succeeded in all these aspects.
What is the purpose of the New Testament? For us to come to believe that Jesus is the promised Christ, the Son of God. And then, by believing, we may have life through his name. (John 20:30)
I personally believe that the New Testament is inspired, but not because of 2 Timothy 3:16. I believe it is inspired because it has accomplished in my life what God had intended for it: for me to come to believe that Jesus is the Christ, my mediator and Savior.
I continue to be astounded on a daily basis at the beauty and harmony of the Hebrew/Aramaic and Greek Scriptures. The aforementioned discrepancies to me are like the wrinkles in the face of my beloved grandmother. Where Atheists and Muslims see flaws and would expect a pristine youthful skin as evidence of her beauty, I instead see beauty in her symptoms of age. It teaches me humility and to avoid dogmatism and empty arguments over words. I am grateful that God’s word was written by imperfect people.
We should not be blind to discrepancies in the resurrection account, but embrace them as part of God’s Inspired Word and be ready to make a defense for what we believe.
Two suicides in one congregation
I wrote his article because a close friend told me that his congregation suffered two suicides in the span of less than two months. One of our brothers hung himself in a garden house. I do not know the details of the other suicide.
Mental disease and depression are ruthless and can affect all people, but I can’t help but imagine that things may relate to their perspective on life and their hope.
Truly, I speak from my own experience growing up. I accepted the words of my parents and trusted elders who told me I would have eternal life on earth, but I personally never thought I was worthy and found peace with the thought that death was just fine in case I would not qualify. I remember telling brothers that I did not serve Jehovah because I hoped to receive a reward, but because I knew that it was the right thing to do.
It would take self-delusion to think we are worthy by our own power to receive everlasting life on earth despite our sinful actions! Even Scripture reasons that none can be saved through the Law since we are all sinners. So I must assume that these poor witnesses simply concluded that their lives were “Meaningless! Utterly Meaningless!”
Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that Christ is not the mediator for all Christians, but only for a literal number of 144,000. [2] Those two witnesses who hung themselves never were taught that Christ died for them personally; that his blood personally wiped their sins away; that he personally would mediate with the Father on their behalf. They were told that they were unworthy of partaking of his blood and body. They were led to believe that they had no life within themselves and that any hope they had was only by extension. They had to forsake all things for the Kingdom without ever having the hope of meeting the King. They had to work harder in every aspect of life without a personal guarantee through the Spirit that they were adopted as God’s Sons.
Jesus said to them, “Very truly I tell you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you” – John 6:53
At the U.S. Branch Visit meeting in November 2014, brother Anthony Morris of the Governing Body of Jehovah’s Witnesses reasoned from Ezekiel that those who are inactive in preaching the Good News have blood on their hands. But this same Governing Body denies the Good News that Christ's ransom is for all (limiting it to only 144000 Christians throughout all ages) in blatant contradiction of Scripture:
“For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, a man, Christ Jesus, who gave himself a corresponding ransom for all.” – 1 Tim 2:5-6
In light of the two suicides, I must think that perhaps Anthony Morris was right about having blood on our hands if we fail to speak truth. And I say this not in a spirit of sarcasm, but looking inwardly, so as to recognize our own responsibility. It is true that to an extent that I am and have been fearful of being judged by my fellow witnesses when it comes to declaring the true Good News.
Yet at the memorial, when I publicly declare that there is no other mediator between me and Jehovah God but Christ, I am giving a testimony of my faith, declaring that his death is our life (1 Co 11:27). For some time prior to my first partaking I was very fearful, but I meditated about Christ’s words:
Therefore everyone who confesses me before men, I will also confess him before My Father who is in heaven. Whoever denies me before men, him I will also deny before my Father in heaven. – Matthew 10:32-33
Should we choose to attend such a memorial with Jehovah’s Witnesses, I pray we all have the courage to stand up for Christ and confess him. I also pray that I may do this every day of my life for the rest of my life.
The other day I was thinking about my own life. I very much feel like Solomon. The opening to this article did not come out of thin air, it comes from my own experience. If I did not have Christ, life would be hard to bear.
I was also thinking about friends, and came to the conclusion that true friends should be able to share their deepest emotions and feelings and hopes without fear of being judged.
Truly, without the assurance we have in Christ, our life would be empty and meaningless!
[1] Barnes, Albert (1997), Barnes’ Notes
[2] Worldwide Security Under the "Prince of Peace" (1986) pp.10-11; The Watchtower, April 1, 1979, p.31; God's Word For Us Through Jeremiah p.173.
Archived Comments
We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.
Comment by umbertoecho on 2015-03-04 16:24:19
Alex. Thank you for this article. I have often thought along the same lines yet have been unable to truly share those thoughts. I am relieved to find once and for all time, the Christ that was denied me as a child growing up in this religion. There was this deliberate block of words put in my way by virtue of the reading literature, studies, meetings and so on.....I grew up in this religion and felt lonely all the time, afraid all the time, guilty..........all the time. It wasn't until about two years ago that I discovered this site and found others who were concerned about the "lack" of Christ within the most basic of teachings within this organization. I had lost people I loved dearly and now it seemed I faced my own lonely death with no hope for a future. It all seemed so pointless and cold.
I think you showed great emotion in a balanced and honest way with this refection of yours and I like that in any person. Christ wasn't afraid to show emotion in an open way, was he?
I know an elder who is such a lovely man, very kind to his family and riddled with childhood guilt's. His work load is huge and now that he is in his sixties, he is pioneering and taking on even more. I really like this man and his wife, they have been exceptionally kind to me even though they now know I disagree with many of their teachings and their (sometimes) heartless ethics. He is not well and is out there everyday in the blistering heat, trying to work his way into some future life that has been mapped out for him by the GB. He has fought suicidal inclinations and his wife has been at the end of her resources at times in an effort to inspire him to stay "happier, content" with what he is and who he is. They have taken all that the GB have said as gospel. It seems to me that the GB have locked heaven and even life on earth...........up, for so many decent people.
I know this is a long reply to your' article Alex but you must know that it has touched me deeply and made me want to tell you about this kind man and his family. He has no hope for heaven, does not partake and is guilt ridden about things done long ago when a child. Why does this happen?
He has multiple health issue Alex. So why do they let him work himself to death in his effort to please this religions version of what constitutes...a good Christian. Hah! How ironic that they class themselves as such.Reply by Barnabas on 2016-04-22 09:25:39
Hello Umbertoecho,
I relate to much of what you shared in this post - raised (from age 11) as a witness and quickly becoming riddled with guilt, fear and loneliness. I could never understand how I was supposed to experience the refreshment as promised by Christ in Matthew 11:28-30. Now Im beginning to realise, that the load heaped on us by the governing body, are loads and expectations of men. Now Ive started to see and understand scriptural truths away from this self-professed body of men, I am slowly beginning to understand just how being under Christs yoke is a good place to be. (but I have a huge uphill struggle)
I also find that visiting jwbroadcast, even a kh, adds to my feelings of guilt, and I find this very unsettling and disturbing.
I hope that one day, I may be able to stop persecuting myself (for my own past sins and errors) and experience the real freedom that comes with following Christ.
Comment by on 2015-03-04 16:26:18
Absolutely wonderful (from the heart) article! You have given me strength to also publicly declare that there is no other than Christ. I have never participated in the emblems for fear of not being worthy but I feel this message has to be shared and not hidden for fear of (men) being labeled mentally diseased. Thank you for your contribution.
Reply by Alex Rover on 2015-03-04 16:55:52
Thank you, your comment gives me great joy.
Comment by Joel on 2015-03-04 16:42:05
Very nicely said. I completely relate to this:
“I remember saying brothers that I do not serve Jehovah because I hoped to
receive a reward, but because I knew that it was the right thing to do.”
I remember saying something similar to others also about my baptism. Of course I was taught from birth it was “dedication”, so I accepted it as a vow, but I had one or 2 issues in the baptism questions relating to “dedication” which caused a bit of hassle. Really in my mind I wanted to declare which side I am on. I always thought of Hananiah, Mishael, and Azariah:
16 “O Nebuchadnezzar, we have no need to answer you in this matter. 17 If this be so, our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the burning fiery furnace, and he will deliver us out of your hand, O king. 18 But if not, be it known to you, O king, that we will not serve your gods or worship the golden image that you have set up.”
Every word of their reply is so well chosen and at the end of the day, isn’t it what this life is really about?
From Genesis 3 – “I will put emnity between your and the woman and between your seed and her seed”
to Revelation 13 – “If anyone worships the beast and his image, and receives his mark on his forehead or on his hand, he himself shall also drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is poured out full strength into the cup of His indignation.”
God had a plan for redemption all along, but as you well said, the issue is not the reward - it is whose side you are on.
Comment by ¿Wheresenoch? on 2015-03-04 17:07:14
Alex, i was wondering if there was any conclusive evidence that the Lords evening meal was 2 be celebrated annually according 2 scripture? If not, then there was a more frequent commemoration. This would greatly depreciate the j.w. Memorial. Therefore would it be better or worse partaking @ such an invalid event based on 1 Cor 11:17-22 due 2 the unrest & detraction from the sacredness of the occasion??
Reply by Alex Rover on 2015-03-04 17:21:22
Hi WheresEnoch,
JW celebrate it annually as a continuation of Pesach. Since we are no longer under the law, you could say it's not mandatory to celebrate it on that day. However, Jesus instituted a new covenant on that day, and then said "keep doing this in remembrance of me". So there is a case to be made for a celebration on Pesach.
On the other hand, the scriptures say "as often as you ..." so it indicates bread was broken on more than this occasion alone, as you mention 1 Corinthians 11:20-34. Personally I feel like it's proper to observe the memorial on the date, and again as often as I feel it is proper and solemn. Hypothetically speaking, say I would meet with Apollos and Meleti once a year in person, we might feel like breaking bread together and drinking from the cup together is a proper expression of our common hope in Christ, with brothers that I recognize as mine in Christ.
Some don't recognize the JW memorial and choose to partake in private or at home. It's good if we can find some others to partake with, and I can't object to that. If they would disfellowship me then I would no longer attend JW memorials either. But if we do choose to go to a memorial, my personal conscience dictates that I do have to declare Christ. It's my choice to attend their memorial, it's my duty to declare Christ if I do. At least that's how I feel.
Comment by ¿Wheresenoch? on 2015-03-04 19:15:04
Thanks. Thats a clear explanation. My memorial attendance is out of habit as well as diffusing confusion. However in light of 1Cor 10:30-32, my partaking is in private. Simply because J.w. Memorial is a farce. Its a commercialized version of what Jesus instituted. The campaigns, memorial season push 2 pioneer, invitations 2 any & everybody... I feel if Christ wanted the whole of mankind 2 celebrate this event he would have introduced it @ the sermon on the mount or some other crowded occasion. Not in a private setting with his 12 closest friends.
Comment by imacountrygirl2 on 2015-03-05 05:19:55
Alex, I have found this post to be deeply moving...because it comes straight from your heart. I can truly feel your sincerity.
The suicides seem to have touched you and caused you deep reflection.
Mental illness is a complex and often misunderstood subject. The brain can misfire or break, just like any other organ or part of the body. Chemicals in the brain can become imbalanced by genetics, heredity and/or situational, based on life's circumstances.
Mental illness is not a personal failure and it does not make you a bad person. None of us choose it. It is what it is, just another illness like diabetes, high blood pressure or heart disease that we frail humans have to deal with, in ourselves and in others.
Suicide in particular causes so much pain...since the person is gone, we can't ask them why they did it. Family and friends are tormented by the thought that they must have missed the signals. The suicide victim is beyond any help or intervention.
Many years ago, a young pioneer brother in our congregation said he was sick and stayed home one Sunday morning during the CO's visit. His family came home to find that he had shot and killed himself. It haunts me to this day that I never suspected anything, never saw his pain behind his beautiful smile and his out-going personality. The pain for me is as if it happened yesterday. Our congregation sort of adopted them when they moved to our town after both their parents died and the oldest brother took on the responsibility of his younger brother and sister. It was the younger brother who killed himself.
You can only wonder about what must have tormented a person to the point that they felt they had no other choice. Alex, I'm sure some must feel like their life is meaningless, but for some they have so many problems that they cannot figure out how to solve them and suicide is their only way out of their emotional pain. I know this because I once considered suicide as a way to end my pain and mental anguish. It was the love for my son and knowing that no one else would ever love him the way that I do that forced me to seek professional help. I could not let my pain inflict such damage on my innocent son.
Every life is precious and all of humanity suffers when a person takes their own life.
umbertoecho, "It seems to me that the GB have locked heaven and even life on earth………..up, for so many decent people." I, too, love my brothers and sisters who are trapped in a prison that only exists in their minds. I feel pity for them and it helps me when I ask Jesus to please send the Holy Spirit to them.
I have often contemplated King Solomon. Jehovah loved him and granted him what he asked for, understanding and discernment and God also gave him riches and power. He had it all. Yet he squandered everything he had in order to satisfy his curious mind and his lust. Solomon turned away from God and instead pursued worldly pleasures. He eventually realized the futility of it all. “Meaningless! Meaningless! [..] Utterly meaningless! Everything is meaningless!” – Ecclesiastes 1:2
That is among my most favorite scriptures. For me, it sets life into perspective. It is so easy to get caught up in living our little ever day life that we lose sight of the bigger picture.
Joel, I so appreciated your comment "God had a plan for redemption all along, but as you well said, the issue is not the reward – it is whose side you are on."
For me, the only real value in life is my belief that Jesus is alive and accepting him as my Saviour, and obeying his commandment to love God and to love my neighbor.Reply by Imgonaburn on 2015-03-29 07:19:02
Who really knows what goes on in the mind of a person so overcome by life that they choose to commit suicide? It could have been any number of reasons that caused them such despair. It may not have been anything to do with how they should observe the memorial and its probable that they had completely lost sight of their relationship with Jehovah and Jesus. The anxieties of life can get in our way and swallow up our faith. The mind is a very delicately balanced part of us. I cannot put myself in the shoes of a person who has committed suicide and say that I understand what motivated them to take their own life. But I agree with immacountrygirl2 to the extent that when I have been at my darkest lowest points in life it has been the love of my children that has pulled me back from the brink above anything else. I could never leave them. I could turn my back on the jws but not my dependant children.
Comment by kev c on 2015-03-05 16:55:32
Thanks alex for a fine article again. Im hoping to partake this year with a few local brothers and a sister. Who regularly visit this site. I. Could not partake at the hall as i am not welcome there. The elders told me a couple of years ago that if i partook i would be stumbling the other brothers and sisters. I said what ? By obeying jesus command. I was building a patio today for a customer and the brothers turned up at thier home. They saw me and just walked off the property. I gave my all for those brothers as an elder. So anthony morris thinks we are blood guilty. If we fail to speak the truth does he. Well i spoke the truth and i was kicked out of the religion for it. As for the brothers if they dont turn to christ then the veil will remain over thier hearts. I pity them i just couldnt bear to watch them all publicly reject jesus again at thier so called memorial. Sorry. Kev.
Comment by agapeheartvisions on 2015-03-05 18:27:23
Alex, this article touched my heart on so many levels. Thank you for such a fine, well-thought out article. When one belongs, I mean truely belongs to Jehovah and to Christ, and is a member of the body of Christ, there is such a feeling of peace, joy and the knowledge that this life is NOT all there is. I may go through trials, tribulations, etc... but I KNOW the I am a CHILD of God. Jehovah is my father, my heavenly father, and Jesus is my Lord and Savior. As I'm writing this, a thought just occurred to me...if Jehovah Witnesses call each other Brother and Sister (meaning part of the same family), how can they turn right around and say that Jehovah God is NOT our father, only our friend?!?
Kev. C. My husband was disfellowshipped for pretty much the same reason. He asked the elders questions they either couldn't or wouldn't answer. To shut him up and to prevent others from talking to him, they kicked him out...so much for a loving response from the (ahem) brothers. (Yeah, I'm being sarcastic)
LaRhonda
Comment by Anjinsan on 2015-03-06 11:52:22
Nice one, thanks.
Comment by stonedragon2k on 2015-03-06 13:48:14
Hi Alex,
I really enjoyed your article.
However for yourself and those brothers who have to accept these 'discrepancies' in the Bible, I say 'hold your horses'.
There is a book written called 'Cold Case Christianity' by a former cold case detective in America, J.Warner Wallace. This guy used to be an atheist and had a typical cynical view of life after seeing the mindless violence and death that was part of his everyday job.
However one day on the urging of his friends he decided to use his cold case skills to look at the stories of Christ. After all, as he said the Gospel accounts of Jesus have all the elements of the perfect cold case (no living witnesses, contradictory accounts, events in the distant past, only circumstantial evidence etc).
From his work he realised the Gospels were true and these same 'discrepancies' you mentioned were exactly what he would expect to find from eye witnesses EVEN though they saw EXACTLY the same event.
In any case I urge EVERYBODY to buy his book. It is brilliantly written and each chapter begins with an actual cold case he has solved and he then relates that case with an aspect of the Gospel 'cold case' story.
Although he is a trinitarian (this is never brought up in the book) don't let that put you off. After reading it, you will have a completely different view of these so called discrepancies which in fact reinforce the Bible as the Word of God, not diminishes it.
He also has a blog site http://coldcasechristianity.com/ where there is a wealth of information about defending the 'Christian worldview'. If this guy isn't a brother (despite his mistaken view of God), I don't know who is.
Any case enjoy. I would be interested in your feeback.
Comment by Leenuks on 2016-02-17 20:18:05
I thank you for this article. It means more to me than you realize.
Comment by Anonymous on 2016-12-24 04:11:22
Loved this article!
I don't want to derail it but I have a question: Do JWs believe in immortality of the soul for "144k"?
What scriptures do they use to support this ?Reply by Meleti Vivlon on 2016-12-24 08:03:13
They do not believe that the anointed children of God are immortal in this life, but once resurrected, they get immortality.
Reply by Anonymous on 2016-12-24 13:58:20
Can you help me Find the Memorial invite to the last GB members funeral?
Is that what they say or actually teach?
Comment by Anonymous on 2016-12-24 04:17:27
This article is really good! It could be The foundation of discussing what Inspiration and Infallibility. This scares the average Christian.
http://discussthetruth.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=1402&p=14691&hilit=Infallibility#p14691
I believe Anderesimste drives this point home.
I struggle with this myself...
Comment by Anonymous on 2016-12-24 04:51:11
Sorry one more thing on that point....
Meleti inspiration is what I call "Spirit runs" it's a form of automatic writing Believe it or not... he dreams or thinks as he writes
Apollos- you are a vivid dreamer and you have huge thoughts . I am usually called wordy or I speak in "dreams" or parables . I'm easily misunderstood as you Know because of this....
Everybody "dreams" before writing. It's not brainstorming. Some are just exceptional in the Spirit at this....