“The spirit itself bears witness with our spirit that we are God’s children.” – Romans 8:16
[From ws 1/20 p.20 Study Article 4: March 23 – March 29, 2020]
This is the first of two articles intended to prepare the brothers and sisters for the memorial. Unfortunately, it starts from the base of its readers accepting the doctrine of the little flock being the anointed and the other sheep being the great crowd; also the doctrine that there is a resurrection to heaven and to earth, rather than only an earthly resurrection.
For an in-depth examination on the great crowd and little flock, see here. For an in-depth examination on what is Mankind’s hope for the future? see here.
“Heaven” as the destination for those termed anointed by the Organization is mentioned some 18 times in this article. Of 39 scriptures cited or quoted only 5 contain “heaven(s)(ly)”. They are Kingdom Of the Heavens, David did not ascend to the heavens, holy spirit from heaven, reserved in the heavens.
Hence the inaccurate claim in paragraph 2 in the second part of the sentence that “They become the first to be anointed by holy spirit and given the hope of ruling with Jesus in heaven” [bold ours].
The footnote referenced to “anointed by Holy Spirit” states “Jehovah uses his holy spirit to select a person to rule with Jesus in heaven. By means of his spirit, God gives that person a promise for the future, or “a token in advance.” (Eph. 1:13, 14) These Christians can say that the holy spirit “bears witness,” or makes clear, to them that their reward is in heaven.—Romans 8:16.”. Both these statements are half truths and the scriptures cited support half of the statement. Ephesians 1:13-14 does state that “By means of his spirit, God gives that person a promise for the future, or “a token in advance.”. However, it mentions nothing about going to heaven.
Similarly, Romans 8:16 “bears witness that they are God’s children”, but not where their reward is. By contrast to the Organization’s unscriptural teaching that a small number go to heaven, a search for the phrase “everlasting life” in the NWT Reference Bible will bring back 93 verses from Matthew to Revelation. Even more telling is that heaven(s)(ly) is not mentioned in the context of even 1 of those 93 scriptures. Surely “heaven” would have been mentioned in regard to at least one of the scriptures containing “everlasting life” if it was a genuine hope.
Paragraph 5 similarly makes a half true statement and goes beyond the word of God. It says “In this way, the holy spirit is “a token [a pledge or promise]” given to assure them that in the future they will live forever in heaven and not on earth.—Read 2 Corinthians 1:21, 22”. Notice the scripture is to be read. Please read it for yourself and see what is different between the scripture and the paragraph. Yes, the scripture says the pledge is given, but nothing about the pledge is “given to assure them that in the future they will live forever in heaven and not on earth.“
Paragraph 6 repeats the claim of going to heaven, but only one of the many cited scriptures mentions anything to do with heaven. This is Hebrews 3:1. It says “Consequently, holy brothers, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the apostle and high priest whom we confess—Jesus.”
So, is this case proven for what the Watchtower is teaching? Let us check. What does the word “heavenly” actually mean? In heaven? No. Heavenward? No. It means the “impact of heaven's influence on the particular situation or person.”. What this means is that the calling or being chosen is by God, evidenced by the Holy Spirit, rather than by say by the demons or by the world. It is a calling from or by heaven as an entity, it has nothing to do with being in that location. A worldly calling would be a call from the world as an entity, not as a physical location. The translation of the verse would be more accurate in conveying the proper meaning if it read “partakers of the calling by / from heaven”.
Paragraph 7 claims “So by means of his holy spirit, God makes it clear to anointed ones that they have this heavenly calling.—1 Thessalonians 2:12”. This is technically true, but as for Hebrews 3:1 in the previous paragraph, it is being misunderstood because of the poor construction of the translation. It would be clearer and convey the true translation better if it read “God makes it clear to anointed ones that they have this calling by heaven. Indeed, because the wrong interpretation of the phrase in the previous paragraph, then this statement will also be interpreted wrongly, thereby perpetuating the error.
Paragraph 8 gives yet another example of an unsubstantiated interpretation. It says “Jehovah leaves no doubt whatsoever in the minds and hearts of those who receive his invitation to go to heaven. (Read 1 John 2:20, 27.)”. If we read the context of these verses, in particular the intervening verses we will see the invitation Jehovah gives, is not to heaven, but to “this is the promised thing that he himself promised us, the life everlasting“ (1 John 2:25).
Please remember this quote from paragraph 8 for next week’s study article “But they do not need anyone to confirm that they are anointed. Jehovah has used the most powerful force in the universe, his holy spirit, to make it absolutely clear to them that they are anointed” when the Watchtower article starts casting aspersions as too whether all who partake at the memorial are really anointed or not!
Paragraph 9 accepts the normal hope of mankind is “God created humans to live forever on earth, not in heaven. (Genesis 1:28; Psalm 37:29)”. But the Study article continues with its erroneous teachings and hence makes a fallacious claim saying “But Jehovah has chosen some to live in heaven. So when he anoints them, he changes their hope and way of thinking drastically, so that they look forward to life in heaven“. Try as you will, you will not find a single scripture that supports either of these pieces of speculation.
Paragraph 11 states “What change in thinking takes place when Christians are anointed? Before Jehovah anointed these Christians, they treasured the hope of living forever on earth.” It goes on to say “But after they were anointed, they started to think differently. Why is that? They did not become dissatisfied with that earthly hope. They did not change their mind because of emotional stress or turmoil. They did not suddenly feel that they would find living forever on earth to be boring. Instead, Jehovah used his holy spirit to change the way that they think and the hope that they cherish”. The really serious question we need to ask is, that as the Bible does not clearly teach a hope of life in the spirit realm “to be like God, KNOWING good and bad” (Genesis 3:4) is it the same spirit that deceived Eve that is deceiving them? Jesus warned that “false anointed ones and false prophets will arise and will give great signs and wonders so as to mislead, if possible, even the chosen ones” (Matthew 24:24).
Paragraphs 14-17 deal with the question: Has Jehovah anointed you?
One sign many Witnesses use to judge if someone is anointed is “Do you feel that you are especially zealous in the preaching work?”
Were all 1st Century Christians especially zealous in the preaching work? Ephesians 4:11 tells us “And he gave some as apostles, some as prophets, some as evangelizers, some as shepherds and teachers”. Clearly, then, not all were especially zealous in preaching or evangelizing. All had different gifts and strengths “for the building up of the body of the Christ”.
Another sign used to judge others is “Do you feel that Jehovah has given you wonderful results in the preaching work?”
Feelings can be mistaken, facts are reliable. Is there any scriptural backup for this suggested qualification? No. Remember the parable of the slaves and the talents (amongst others) in Matthew 25:14-28? The slaves were all rewarded, but because of their efforts, not their results.
After asking a whole lot of questions that most Witnesses would expect any who claim to be anointed to be able to answer yes to all of them, the article tries to surprise us by saying “If you answer these questions with a resounding yes, does this prove that you now have the heavenly calling? No, it does not. Why not? Because all of God’s servants can feel this way, whether they are anointed or not”. The main problem with this statement is that most unawakened Witnesses will continue to judge others by those very questions, that they will remember, but conveniently for the Organization forget that the article stated that “all of God’s servants can feel this way.”
Paragraph 15 sadly repeats most of the Organization’s speculative teachings as to who cannot rule with Christ.
For example, King David, who although he was used by Jehovah in a large way, including writing many Psalms, learnt from his mistakes, showing repentance. Yet, somehow, he is not worthy of ruling over mankind using Acts 2:34 as so-called proof. It is no proof at all.
The Organization also claims John the Baptist will not rule with Christ despite Christ saying, “Among those born of women there has not been raised up a greater than John the Baptist;”.
On what basis is this claim made? The Watchtower gives no basis for the statement “Jehovah used his holy spirit to give these men the power to do amazing things, but he did not use that spirit to choose them to live in heaven”. Speculation, yet again.
What about the principle of James 1:21-23 which says “Abraham put faith in Jehovah, and it was counted to him as righteousness, and he came to be called ‘Jehovah’s friend’”. He was the only human to be called God’s friend in the scriptures.
The entire chapter 11 of Hebrews discusses men and women of faith who lived before Christ came to earth. What does Hebrews 11:39-40 tell us about them? “And yet all these, although they had witness borne to them through their faith, did not get the [fulfillment of the] promise, 40 as God foresaw something better for us, in order that they might not be made perfect apart from us”.
Yes, Hebrews states that those faithful men and women of old would not be made perfect at a separate time and place to the Apostle Paul and his fellow first century Christians. The Greek word translated “apart” conveys the meaning of “apart from, separated ("without"); (figuratively) detached, rendering something invalid or valid.”. So, just to reiterate what the Apostle Paul wrote, he said that the likes of Noah, Abraham, David etc, would not be made perfect without the Apostle Paul and his fellow Christians. It would only be a valid event if it happened this way. (See also 1 Thessalonians 4:15).
By going beyond God’s word, the Organization has created so many unnecessary problems and questions. So many problems and questions, that the following week’s Watchtower Study article is written to attempt to answer them. “Because some anointed ones are still among God’s people today, certain questions naturally arise. (Rev. 12:17) For example, how should anointed ones view themselves? If someone in your congregation starts to partake of the emblems at the Memorial, how should you treat that person? And what if the number of those who say that they are anointed keeps on growing? Should you be concerned about it?” (par.17).
Conclusion
When we accept the Bible’s teachings “that there is going to be a resurrection of both the righteous and the unrighteous” (Acts 24:15), “since they will inherit the earth”, (Matthew 5:5) and “He that exercises faith in the Son has everlasting life;” (John 3:36, Luke 18:20) and that we should “Keep doing this, as often as YOU drink it, in remembrance of me.” For as often as YOU eat this loaf and drink this cup, YOU keep proclaiming the death of the Lord, until he arrives” (1 Corinthians 11:25-26) thereby showing appreciation for Christ’s sacrifice; then all these questions and more, actually evaporate. The truth of God’s promises is simple.
Let us be resolved not to let man’s complicated teachings confuse us, but to let the simple truth shine through on our lives as Jesus taught us by showing others we are Christ’s disciples because “By this all will know that YOU are my disciples, if YOU have love among yourselves.”(John 13:35), and then “If YOU remain in my word, YOU are really my disciples, 32 and YOU will know the truth, and the truth will set YOU free.” (John 8:31-32).
Archived Comments
We have moved to the Disqus commenting system. To post a new comment, go to the bottom of this page.
Comment by exquisite inquisite on 2020-03-30 11:05:12
Hi Tadua, hello everyone.
Im new to this group. Im a current JW but been sitting on the fence so to speak for the last year now probably. I was born into the Organisation and was always a side liner, never really threw myself into it. I had moments of zeal in my teen years, which lead me to baptism at the age of 17. More for the reason of my mother saying "its about time", but i had more desire to go traveling and see the world.
Im now fast approaching 40 and have a family of my own.
I first heard of the royal commission which i watched entirely, and this lead me to youtube and the rest speaks for itself.
One channel that stuck out for me was Erics. I felt uncomfortable listening to the majority of exjw content, but always felt uplifted and satisfied after listening to Eric. So thank you Eric.
The lack of zeal i had before seems to have gone into overdrive now i feel i can think for myself!
I have been following your watchtower reviews for the last 6 months or so now Tadua, even had them on my phone at he kingdom hall instead of the jw app ! think a brother spotted that on the roving mics a while back ! made me chuckle.
But i just wanted to say how much i appreciate what you are all doing on here, I enjoy all the articles, and everyones input in the comments. I really feel im now learning "what does the bible REALLY teach" .
I have no idea what will happen to me regarding leaving yet. Any advice would be much appreciated.
keep up the good work everybody, and look forward to getting involved.
Your brotherReply by Meleti Vivlon on 2020-03-30 13:28:10
Welcome to the ever-expanding community of freed Christians, Exquisite Inquisite.
Reply by Leonardo Josephus on 2020-03-31 04:29:02
HI Ex, and also welcome. I think I have been on this site for nearly 5 years. I am not sure I believe that myself. When I first came here it was like everyone was encouraging us just to get out. Apart from Eric, not many of those names still appear, although one or two pop up now and then. However, from fighting against the Org, this site has shown how to discuss matters reasonably, and has gone a long way towards being decent spiritual forum. So much credit to Eric for that, of course.
Most of the flaws of WT teachings have been exposed. The result is that at least mentally we have become free. We become like Naaman, if we are PIMOs, as we feel there is not a lot we can do if we have family who are still in.
Be determined to not let anyone control your mind, and you will be free. I am quite sure that the powers above understand where we are. Maybe the day will come when I put my foot in it and get disfellowshipped. Then so be it. Maybe I cannot continue as I am, and disassociate one day. Time will tell. But Jesus said that "You will know the truth and the truth will set you free". But then, what is freedom ? It reminds me of the series "the Prisoner" from the 1960s. You can spend your life fighting to escape, and Partick McGoohan as number 6 got there eventually, while everyone else was quite content with the status quo. But They were not free.
Just make sure that what you have is the truth, and you will be free. Do not let others tell you what you must do to please God. Be guided by your understanding. Yes, in some cases the truth may not be clear, as evidenced by some of the discussions on this site. It is not wrong to be unsure, just be sure you know why you are unsure. Is anyone really free in this system ?
Love to all.
Comment by Nightingale on 2020-03-23 06:41:35
Great analysis, thanks! What a mess the organization has created with its heaven obsession!
It's also interesting how the Org seems to teach that there are Christians who are anointed with holy spirit and then Christians who merely have holy spirit - but the Bible doesn't make such a difference.
Another thing: where does the Bible say that anointing with the holy spirit is a separate event than the baptism in the name of Father, Son and the Holy spirit? In other words that someone is baptized first and then "anointed" with holy spirit only later on? Does the Bible support such an idea?
And it's interesting that Jws always talk about "anointed Christians" even though that term is nowhere in the Bible...
Comment by wild olive on 2020-03-23 08:40:12
So true Nightingale, the term anointed Christian doesn’t appear in the bible because it’s a doubled up term. The word “Christ” means anointed , so a follower of “Christ” is anointed as well, the person can’t be Christian and be unanointed , just not possible. JWs don’t seem to see the irony in the terminology, but, that’s the power of propaganda.
Comment by Leonardo Josephus on 2020-03-23 08:52:08
Tadua, that was probably your most thorough dissection of a W article that I have read. It was a tough subject and I really appreciated your thoughts. I have been carefully considering this subject for some time, so these are simply my thoughts on the subject :-
Anointing is presented as a mystery, rather like the Trinity. There is not enough to support the teaching in the scriptures themselves.
When Romans 8:16 says " the spirit bears witness with our spirit that we are God's children" it seemed to me that it means that when we read God's word, we show by our actions that we want to be part of his family, i.e his children. When Hebrews 4:12 says God's word divides between soul and spirit, it is saying much the same.
God's spirit acts as a witness that we are God's children, when what we do is what He and his son have told us is right and we apply it.
When Romans 8:4-6 asks us to "Walk according to the spirit, etc", it is asking us to allow God to direct us in our lives and focus on what pleases him.
Of course, in the first century, there was the outpouring of holy spirit at Pentecost. This was a special operation of holy spirit.
The expression "anointed" appears few times in the Christian Greek Scriptures, and usually applies to Jesus (Luke 4:18, Acts 4:26-7, 10:38, Hebrews 1:9). On four occasions (2 Corinthians 1:21, and 21 John 2:20,27 (twice)) it is applied to Christians. As the readers probably were not at Pentecost, the meaning of "anointed" in these verses must be similar to "sealed", and could apply to the hope of being with Christ in heaven, much as "Born again" Christians would express matters, or it may apply simply, as you have said, to everlasting life, wherever that proves to be.
In the 20th century , there is no evidence that there has been any special anointing other than what the scriptures allude to. I do not see the Bible connect "holy spirit" with "anointing" other than what would seem to be an application of what happened to give early Christians the power to speak in tongues, and to heal.
What the GB teach is what they have said for many years, making it some mysterious operation of the holy spirit, namely that somehow (para 7) God makes it clear to them that they have this heavenly calling. And, they protect the understanding by discouraging all questions on the matter, which probably means they are still getting questions, but do not wish to answer them.
Of course, as you rightly explain, Tadua, a heavenly calling simply tells us where the calling comes from, not where it is to.
Unfortunately when someone claims to have been chosen in some special way, we can simply say "how wonderful", but it does not seem to be the way it was in the first century. Alternatively we can use our power of reason and the scriptures to see something just is not quite right, however sincere those at the helm may seem to be.
Comment by marielle on 2020-03-23 12:52:22
Oui, ils font de cette onction divine, quelque chose de plus en plus mystérieux, à tel point qu’il devient inconvenant de poser des questions.
En effet, comme le dit Leonardo Josephus, ils doivent toujours recevoir des questions sur ce sujet nébuleux.
En témoigne la dernière vidéo d’Anthony Morris intitulée : « peut-on comprendre l’appel céleste » ?
On s’attend enfin à recevoir une réponse claire, aussi « clairement » que Jéhovah leur témoigne qu’ils sont oints.
Mais non, toujours pas !
Cette vidéo montre Anthony Morris interloqué, écoutant la sœur, qui a posé la question à F Frantz : « Comment sais-tu que tu es oint » ?
Comment ?
Tu as posé cette question à ce monument spirituel ?
Il dit : « Ce n’est pas que la sœur voulait être CURIEUSE ».
Non, simplement, elle a dit CE QUI LUI PASSAIT PAR LA TÊTE !
Donc, soit nous sommes curieux, et nous nous mêlons de ce qui ne nous regarde pas.
Soit, nous passons pour des écervelés qui parlent sans réfléchir.
En résumé, nous sommes pénibles, puisque Anthony Morris trouve qu’il faut vraiment faire preuve de patience envers les brebis de Jéhovah, qui posent encore ce genre de question.
Depuis quand, le témoignage clair et irréfutable de l’esprit, ne doit pas servir à l’édification de l’assemblée ? C’est une première dans l’histoire biblique !
La sœur, qui ne met certainement pas en doute la spiritualité de F Frantz, n’aura toujours pas la réponse précise qu’elle attend.
Elle se contentera de la citation du verset de Romains 8 : 16,17.
Comme le dit justement Tadua, Romains 8 : 16 ne parle pas d’un esprit qui témoigne à un nombre limité de personnes qui auraient l’espoir de vivre dans les cieux.
Mais l’esprit témoigne à leur esprit, qu’ils sont « enfants de Dieu ».
Que nous dit le verset 11?
« Si l’esprit de celui qui a ressuscité Jésus HABITE en vous, celui qui a ressuscité Christ Jésus rendra la vie à vos corps mortels, GRÂCE À SON ESPRIT QUI HABITE EN VOUS ».
Nous ne pouvons espérer ressusciter, si nous n’avons pas l’esprit de Dieu en nous.
Dans tout ce chapitre 8 Paul ne change pas d’auditoire, et s’adresse à tous ceux qui, libérés de la loi du péché et de la mort, ont la vie, selon la loi de l’esprit, en union avec Christ. (v 2)
Qui sont « les enfants de Dieu » pour Jean ?
I Jean 3 : 1
« Voyez quel genre d’amour le Père nous a donné, pour que nous soyons APPELÉS ENFANTS DE DIEU » !
Chose étrange, la TG 15 15/9 P18-22
Base son étude sur ce verset, mais n’en cite que la première partie.
Elle explique donc, que TOUS LES CHRÉTIENS sont l’objet de l’amour de Dieu, sans jamais dire, que si Dieu nous aime, c’est pour que nous soyons appelés « ENFANTS DE DIEU ».
Nous avons un Père qui nous aime, nous sommes ses enfants, ou les « enfants de Jéhovah » § 11.
Mais pas LES ENFANTS DE DIEU qui, selon la fin du verset 1 et le verset 2 « attendent que cela soit manifeste ».
Pourquoi faire ce découpage, au verset 1 ?
Ils ne peuvent pas dire que Dieu n’aime que 144 000 personnes, puisque « Dieu a tant aimé le monde qu’il a donné son Fils, pour que quiconque ait foi en lui, ait la vie éternelle ».
Ils choisissent donc de ne traiter que la première partie du verset,
Car si nous sommes « enfants de Dieu, nous entrons dans la catégorie des héritiers de Dieu, et cohéritiers de Christ ». Romains 8 : 17.
Aucun texte biblique n’indique que certains chrétiens NE BÉNÉFICIERAIENT PAS d’une onction particulière, ni que celle-ci serait réservée à un nombre limité de chrétiens, au-delà de la Pentecôte.
Qui plus est, un nombre limité au premier siècle, qui devait s’accroître à nouveau, entre la fin du XIX et début du XX siècle, puis diminuer ensuite, pour cause d’annonce ou de proposition d’une autre espérance.
(Je ne parle pas du nombre pratiquement complet, censé diminuer depuis 1935, mais qui s’accroît ces dernières années. Plus de 20 000 l’année précédente). Là encore, le « governing body » ne manque pas de faire passer certains frères et sœurs qui prennent le pain et le vin de Christ, pour des déséquilibrés !
Paul, qui lui, a reçu une révélation divine, nous dit: « Il y a UN SEUL ESPRIT, UNE SEULE ESPÉRANCE ».
À nous d’adapter nos croyances à ce que disent les Écritures inspirées.
Amitiés fraternelles à tous.
Comment by Frankie on 2020-03-28 05:51:15
Thank you Tadua for excellent article, very useful especially on the upcoming occasion of the Memorial. I would also like to express some thoughts on the term anointing, which some of the brothers and sisters mention.
The King is always anointed. The secular king is anointed with oil; the king in the kingdom of God is anointed with holy Spirit. In this case, Jesus Christ is anointed as King of the God's Kingdom. And other Christians are also anointed because they will rule with him - the royal priesthood (1 Pet 2:9, Rev 1:6).
The Holy Spirit is given to everyone on the occasion of baptism, sometimes before baptism (Acts 10: 34-48) and sometimes after that (Acts 8: 14-17). The Holy Spirit descended upon Jesus as a dove (Matt 3:16). When Christians receive holy Spirit, it is expressed differently: descended, came on them, poured. It is not even written at Pentecost that Christians were anointed - but were "filled" (Acts 2:4).
Apostle Paul wrote: "And it is God who establishes us with you in Christ, and has anointed us, and who has also put his seal on us and given us his Spirit in our hearts as a guarantee" (1 Cor 1:21-22). Hence, God anointed us, and these anointing serves as a guarantee, as a seal. Who can break the seal God has given?
So every Christian received holy Spirit, everyone was anointed and everyone was sealed. Therefore, John rightly speaks of anointing (1 John 2: 20,27). The phrase "anointed Christians" does not appear in the Bible, but John addresses Christians and says they are anointed.
The problem is not that Christians are not anointed, the problem is that the WT divides Christians into anointed and non-anointed. For if Christians were not anointed, they could not even be Christians in the sense of 1 Cor 1: 21-22 and Rev 1:6. They would not have the Spirit in their hearts and would not be sealed and would not be kings.
Love to all here. FrankieReply by Leonardo Josephus on 2020-03-28 16:18:19
Hi Frankie. Well done. I believe your last two paragraphs sum it all up very well, and are in line with scripture. No mystery, just the position. Holy spirit at or before baptism ? Certainly for many first century Christians, but I will take a rain check on how that applies to Christians today. We may be guided by holy spirit, because we are guided by God's word, but that does not mean we receive it at baptism, at least not as some special gift. After all, did not Paul say that these gifts would cease ?
Either way, I really appreciated your thoughts. I just cannot work out why I could not put it so simply myself.Reply by Frankie on 2020-03-28 17:11:23
Hello LJ. Thank you for your kind response. You are right, the special gifts ceased. Nevertheless the holy Spirit remains in heart of every devoted Christian, and it is certainly in your heart, with respect to many your spiritual comments here. Agape to you. Frankie
Comment by tell sackket on 2020-04-08 20:52:22
Hi I have been a witness for a long time born in the truth etc you all know the story .
question, Paul says the spirit speaks to our spirit we r sons of God etc..
does that mean that we have a spirit which is not what we r taught
If the holy spirit is an active force with no personality how can it speak
regards Tell
Comment by The Great Crowd of Other Sheep Praise God and Christ - Awaken JW's on 2021-03-19 14:49:51
[…] “Look! A Great Crowd” Mankind’s hope for the future. Where will it be? – A Scriptural Examination – Part 6 “The Spirit Itself Bears Witness” […]